Monday, July 16, 2007

In Service to the Common Good

Bahá’í Youth


in Their Own Words







Bahá’í Youth
in Their Own Words

Preface
Early in 2005, the National Spiritual Assembly asked a task force of volunteers
to continue the narrative about Bahá’ís and social action, begun in
2004 and published as In Service to the Common Good: The American
Bahá’í Community’s Commitment to Social Change.
Composed mainly of young adults, the task force focused on Bahá’í
youth: their concerns; their views on the world and their place in it; and the
role they are playing, or preparing to play, in promoting social change in the
United States. The volunteers investigated these issues through interviews,
an online survey, and research in the literature on youth.
What the task force found was a pattern of commitment to service.
Whether singly or as part of organized initiatives, young Bahá’ís are learning
to offer their insight, energy and dedication to the communities in which
they live.
Moreover, adults and Bahá’í institutions support them in a variety of
ways, including through the creation of programs designed to develop
youths’ capacities, whether they are members of the Bahá’í Faith or of the
community at large.
As in last year’s report, the information and stories that follow are a
small sample of a larger reality. What could not be told here is the story of
the thousands of young Bahá’ís who, heeding the guidance of their teachings
and of the institutions of their Faith, are preparing themselves through study
and action for the larger role they will play in our nation’s future.
“The foundation of all their accomplishments,” writes the Universal House
of Justice, the Bahá’í Faith’s highest governing body, “is their study of the
teachings, the spiritualization of their lives, and the forming of their characters
in accordance with the standards of Bahá’u’lláh….” Specifically, the House of
Justice says, “It is the obligation of a Bahá’í to educate his children; likewise
it is the duty of the children to acquire knowledge of the arts and sciences and
to learn a trade or a profession whereby they, in turn, can earn their living and
support their families. This, for a Bahá’í youth, is in itself a service to God….”
It is often said that America’s youth are its future. It is equally true that
young people even now enrich our lives as they prepare to assume in full
measure the responsibilities implicit in their high destiny. We commend
these glimpses of their stories to your attention, in the hope that you will
share our optimism and excitement about our common future.
THE NATIONAL SPIRITUAL ASSEMBLY OF THE
BAHÁ’ÍS OF THE UNITED STATES
December 2005
2 In Service to the Common Good
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
In Service to the
Common Good:
Bahá’í Youth in
Their Own Words . . . . . . . . 3
Profile: Orien Aid . . . . . . . 12
Snapshots of Service:
KWSP and the
Ark Project . . . . . . . . . . . 15
Insights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
Media Training Pilot . . . 17
Umoja Souljahs . . . . . . . 18
When asked to choose from a list of goals
for their lives in the future, nine out of ten
young Bahá’ís say “doing service.”1 They
say they want to “make a difference in the
world,” and to dedicate themselves to
education, good health, having strong
friendships and a “close relationship with
God.” Nearly 60 percent of those responding
said they have done or plan to do a
year of service, a program for young people
administered in the United States by agencies
of the National Spiritual Assembly of the
Bahá’ís of the United States, and one which
operates domestically and internationally.
“Helping others” is a big part of the
definition of service to these young people,
and the world seems to call for their involvement
in many different areas. One group
of youth produced a list of concerns about
society that included “poverty, racism,
environmental destruction, extremes of
wealth and poverty, religious fanaticism,
closed-mindedness, war, terrorism and the
need for world peace, AIDS and other
diseases, and putting into action the
equality of men and women.”
Bahá’í youth see in these concerns a
summons to action and a framework for
their preparation for service: More than 60
percent say they hope to choose, or have
already chosen, a field of study that fits
with their Bahá’í beliefs.
Why are young Bahá’ís so adamant
about service? Partly it is because young
people tend to be concerned about others,
and about society and its challenges: In his
2001 study, Real Teens, George Barna, a
well-known Christian researcher, found
that 62 percent of his respondents listed
“how much the church is involved in helping
poor and disadvantaged people” as an
important feature of the congregation
they would choose after leaving home.
This involvement serves as a good practical
measure of the “heart” of the congregation,
Barna says, and of the community that
develops within it.
Service—At the Core of Bahá’í Teachings
Service is also part of the basic teachings of
the Bahá’í Faith. Bahá’í youth consistently
reference passages on this subject that
can be found in the Bahá’í writings: “Be
anxiously concerned with the needs of
the age ye live in, and center your deliberations
on its exigencies and requirements,”
is one example. “All effort and exertion
put forth by man from the fullness of his
heart is worship,” says ‘Abdu’l-Bahá, son
of Bahá’u’lláh, founder of the Bahá’í Faith,
“if it is prompted by the highest motives
and the will to do service to humanity.
This is worship: to serve mankind and to
minister to the needs of the people. Service
is prayer.” “Service to humanity is service
to God.” “Undoubtedly,” the Universal
House of Justice tells Bahá’í youth, “it is
within your power to contribute significantly
to shaping the societies of the coming
century; youth can move the world.”
Such statements, reinforced by their own
observations, have created a sense among
many young Bahá’ís that constructive change
in society is not only necessary but possible:
Bahá’í Youth in Their Own Words 3
The 2005
Research Project
For nine months, between
March and December 2005,
Bahá’í youth and young adults
talked with their peers regarding
their thoughts and feelings
about the world they live in
and their place in it. They did
this using a survey they created
and administered to people
aged fifteen to twenty-two via
the Internet and over the
phone, and which garnered
responses from more than
1,000 young Bahá’ís; and they
interviewed a number of young
people associated with organized
programs of service and
development.
In Service to the Common Good:
Bahá’í Youth in Their Own Words
“…is there any deed in the world that would be nobler than service to the common good?”
~ ’Abdu’l-Bahá
4 In Service to the Common Good
More than two-thirds of respondents say
they feel “very well prepared for the
uncertainties and challenges to come;”
nine out of ten have adopted the goal of
“making a difference in the
world,” and three-quarters
of them say it is true or
absolutely true that “one
person can make a difference
in the world.”
A Matter of Identity
Young Bahá’ís identify with their
faith, which impels them toward
service. Three-quarters of survey
respondents were raised in Bahá’í
families, although 14 percent of
them say their “parents are/were
Bahá’ís but I feel like I discovered
the faith on my own.” Some 84
percent of respondents say they “love
being a Bahá’í,” 86 percent say they are
“excited about the future of the faith,”
64 percent say their “friends know about
the Bahá’í Faith because I’ve told them
about it,” and 77 percent indicate “the
Bahá’í Faith is one of the most important
things in my life.” “During a typical day I
pray,” report nearly two-thirds of respondents;
82 percent say their “religious beliefs have
helped me to form my personal identity.”
A twenty-one year old expresses her
understanding of service this way: “Freeing
myself from as many thoughts and desires
of my own (as I can), having love for my
fellow men, pure intention, and humility
as one servant of God and being able to
offer myself for humanity.”
Another youth attests: “ ‘For unto whomsoever
much is given, of him shall be much
required.’ This quotation explains why I
choose to act in the ways I do. I know that
I have been given many opportunities for a
reason and it is my task to translate those
opportunities into actions that will allow me
to serve humanity. I used to think that service
consisted of doing something outside of
myself that was beneficial to
the life of another. . . I have
expanded my understanding
to include the attitude with
which I engage in everyday
activities. . . My service right
now is to strive for excellence
in my academics. This does not exclude
me from performing concrete or physical
service, but it allows me to be ‘okay’ with
not doing the same sort of services that I am
accustomed to. . . because the academic
skills that I am acquiring will enable me
to be of more useful and knowledgeable
service in the future.”
Twenty-three year old Anisa writes,
“The faith inspires me to serve and if it
wasn’t for the faith I don’t know if I would
do it at all. But deep down, when I think
about me and who I am, I do it because
it makes me different and for the better.”
Finally, a 21 year-old muses about
his own path, saying “I found my life was
constantly finding service opportunities;
they were right in front of me and taking the
step was all I had to do. The decision was
an easy one, too, since I was surrounded
by my friends who were encouraging me
to serve. . . It was then I realized that. . . the
service to humanity I committed myself to
was the juice that fueled my life.”
Organized Action
About half of those surveyed say they
“organize to take action on issues of social
justice that concern me most” and 45 percent
report they are “very involved in charity or
service projects.” The program profiles that
come later in this booklet offer stories of
Three quarters of
respondents agree
that “one person can
make a difference in
the world.”
“The service
to humanity
I committed
myself to was
the juice that
fueled my life.”
just a few of those organized initiatives,
which range from discussion and networking
conferences for young adults to international
service programs which have been formalized
with not-for-profit status. Let us look, however,
at what these young people are learning
through the process of organizing to address
their concerns, and what kinds of support
they receive—or do not receive—from the
adults and local Bahá’í communities in which
they live.
No Boundaries
“The world is contracting into a neighborhood.
America, willingly or unwillingly, must
face and grapple with this new situation,”
wrote Shoghi Effendi, then head of the
Bahá’í community, in
1939. Writing to the
Bahá’ís of the United
States three years
earlier, he foresaw
that “A mechanism
of world inter-communication
will be devised,
embracing the whole
planet, freed from
national hindrances
and restrictions, and functioning with marvelous
swiftness and perfect regularity.”
Contemporary literature has expanded
on these themes, in light of what has been
learned in the intervening decades. New
York Times columnist and author Thomas
L. Friedman, for example, in his latest book
The World Is Flat, advances the view that
boundaries which once separated people
have been erased by new technologies for
managing communication and work flow, and
suggests that, by using these technologies,
shared goals can be accomplished in ways
scarcely imagined in even the recent past.
Friedman quotes Carly Fiorina, former head
of Hewlett Packard, as saying the future of
collaboration and communication will be
“digital, mobile, personal and virtual.”
Other writers have noted that the current
generation of youth is unlike any previous
one in terms of their technological savvy,
their saturation in media of all kinds, and
their multi-tasking abilities (CBS News, 2004;
Lyons-Cavazos, 2004). They were the first
generation to grow up with hundreds of
cable channels (notable among them, MTV),
computers in the home, cell phones and the
Internet. They are accustomed to fast-paced
media and communication, and their ability
to use the tools at their disposal, often
simultaneously, makes them “totally pluggedin
citizens of a worldwide community.”

(CBS News, 2004)
Bahá’í youth
are using these technologies
to pursue
their goals of service.
One such venture is
Insights, a two-yearold
initiative created
by two friends in their
early 20’s to help their
peers to find community,
seek advice and share experiences about
major life choices—career, family, sexuality,
their place in an increasingly complex global
society, etc.—and explore the application of
the Bahá’í Faith’s principles to all these issues.
The gatherings bring together 100 or
more young people at a time, but Insights
was “hiding in plain sight,” in the words of
one participant, possibly because there is
neither infrastructure nor advertising for
Insights conferences. Young people find
out about Insights events through word
of mouth, email, an increasingly effective
website and instant messaging. These technologies
are also employed in sustaining a
Bahá’í Youth in Their Own Words 5
Nearly half of
Bahá’í youth say
they organize to
take action on
social issues,
and 45% report
they are “very
involved in
charity or service
projects.”
“virtual” community of interest between
events.
Orien Aid is another of the programs
profiled below. While on vacation from
Maxwell International Bahá’í School in British
Columbia, a 19 year-old student visited a
classmate in Rwanda. He saw a need for
volunteers to help with building a clinic;
his approach to meeting that need led to
the formation of Orien Aid in January, 2004
with a group of fellow graduates
from the Maxwell School. The
first group of volunteers, who
came from seven countries in
three continents, were in college
or had recently begun careers.
Through email and cell phone,
they were able to come together
to meet a shared goal.
The other initiatives profiled
in the pages below likewise draw on a
pool of young people who are scattered
throughout the world and who rely on
technology and certain guiding principles
to create communities of interest and carry
out their service.
Consultation is the backbone of the
groups described in the pages that follow.
Bahá’í youth use consultation to choose
topics for Insights workshops, to carry out
daily debriefings during overseas service
projects and to inform their decisions in
every other aspect of their service. Consultation
ensures participants’ safety and their
programs’ success.
Indeed, in many areas of their lives,
young Bahá’ís reach out to others in their
efforts to find answers: Nearly three-quarters
of survey respondents say they have “meaningful
conversations with my parents,” while
almost half say they “have needed a mentor
in my life,” 56 percent that they “will likely
rely on Bahá’í mentors along the way” and
51 percent that “it is easy to find a Bahá’í
mentor if you need one.”
Collective learning and capacity building
lie at the heart of the organized activity of
many Bahá’í youth. Orien Aid, for instance,
6 In Service to the Common Good
Guiding Principles
For many young Bahá’ís, it is not so much what they do, as how they do it. In Service to the Common Good:
The American Bahá’í Community’s Commitment to Social Change (2004) describes five guiding principles that
shape the emerging, worldwide pattern of Bahá’í development. Each of the programs identified in the current
review shows the application of one or more of these principles.
Consultation: “A process of collective decision making and action, devoid of adversarial posturing while
dispassionate and democratic in spirit, is an indispensable feature of every Bahá’í undertaking.”
Participatory Learning: “Promoting collective learning and organizational capacity-building ensures the
sustainability of projects.”
Organic Growth: “Successful social initiatives best begin with simple actions at the local community level
that gradually grow in complexity.”
Moral Development: “Creating moral awareness and moral responsibility is a prerequisite to enlightened
and just action.”
Unity, Equality and Justice: “True social advancement is made possible when every member of society
can trust that they are protected by standards and assured of benefits that apply equally to all. The realization
of justice is dependent upon participation by all social actors.”
In Service to the Common Good (2004)
One reason
consultation is
so important is
because so much
of what Bahá’í
youth do is their
own initiative;
no one tells them
to take action.
has made a five-year commitment to its
partners in Rwanda to achieve sustainability.
Orien’s model is based on working hand in
hand with local residents, rather than simply
doing good works and “giving hand-outs,”
as one participant calls the work of some
other groups he observed in the field.
Organic growth, for
these programs, means
seeing an opportunity
and, through consultation,
following its lead.
The Karen Wallace
Service Project began
slowly: “Every year we go
to Asia because we lived
there when the kids were little,” says one
participant. “This year (2005) was our fourth
trip…(On) the first trip we did some teaching
at the school and some physical maintenance
work. From there it began to develop. My
kids were telling other kids about it (and)
they wanted to take it beyond what they did
last year. That’s how the dance workshop
came up. The schools in Yasothon (Thailand)
all know about us now, and we’re requested
to do more there than we can during our twomonth
stay. We’ve met the governor and so
many amazing things have come out of it.”
Moral development is reflected in
the words of a 13 year-old Umoja Souljah:
“The Umoja Souljahs is a great group for
young black males to get in touch with
their ancestors and learn more about them
and to better themselves. And once they get
inside they’ll say, ‘Well, I didn’t know this
was happening,’ and they’ll start opening
their minds more and then they’ll think
about what they are doing the next time
they are going to get in trouble.”
Her own moral development can be
heard when this young volunteer speaks:
“How do you try to tell someone about
nutrition when they haven’t eaten for the
past two days? How do you teach someone
about trust when ten years ago, their neighbor
killed their entire family? How do you
teach children’s classes with no crayons, no
paper, no Internet, no resources? You have to
rethink everything from an entirely different
perspective and not make
assumptions from our
luxurious lives back home.
It’s a humbling experience,
and you find that everyone
you came to ‘teach’ is
teaching you.”
Finally, young Bahá’ís’
concern for unity, equality
and justice is integral to the contribution
they hope to make. Their approach to every
situation includes questions like: What issue
will we address? Which of my friends can I
involve? What do the local people have to
say? How can we ensure a diverse group of
participants and perspectives? Are the views
of women taken into account, and do they
differ from those of men in this situation?
“The biggest test and struggle for the
group was unity within the group,” writes
one youth. “People, people, people. That
is the only real challenge I think I have ever
faced when it comes to service,” writes
another. Both volunteers knew that unity
was important not just for the group itself,
but for the quality of the service they
offered to others.
Some of the youth interviewed are also
aware of the downside of growing up in the
comparatively privileged environment of the
United States. One young woman worries
whether there is a latent “cultural imperialism”
in her service and reminds herself to
listen, to learn, and not to assume she has
the answers to complex local problems.
“Just because we are from the West or even
Bahá’í Youth in Their Own Words 7
“They’ll start
opening their
minds more, and
then they’ll think
about what they
are doing the next
time they are going
to get in trouble.”
Bahá’ís,” she says,
“does not make us
an authority on every
aspect of life.”
Support Networks
Most young Bahá’ís
have been part of
local Bahá’í communities,
which are
composed of local
administrative institutions
called Local Spiritual Assemblies,2
of adults, family and friends. How are
they supported by these many “others”
in their lives?
Although survey respondents say there
are times when levels of support, respect
and understanding could be higher, they
say they generally feel supported. Indeed,
more than two thirds of respondents say they
are “very well prepared for the uncertainties
or challenges to come” in their lives. Some
49 percent of respondents say they consider
themselves leaders, and 63 percent say they
want to be leaders some day.
Their parents may have been one
source for this confidence: 53 percent of
respondents say their parents have “had
the greatest influence on me,” compared
with 21 percent who attribute greatest
influence to friends and 20 percent to
teachers. Among the general population,
Barna found that 78 percent of teens he
surveyed said their parents had “a lot”
of influence on them, followed by friends
(51 percent) and teachers (34 percent).
Bahá’í administrative institutions have
a responsibility to foster a sense of optimism
and confidence among young people,
and they appear to be doing so with some
success. When asked whether they feel
“encouraged by the Bahá’í administration,”
58 percent
responded “true”
or “absolutely true.”
In the same vein,
60 percent say youth
are supported by
local Assemblies
in their individual
initiatives and 67
percent say they
feel they have what
they need to be
active in the Bahá’í community.
Nearly half (46 percent) say they are
“very active” in the Bahá’í community and
that the community “supports most anything
youth want to do” (63 percent). More than
half (56 percent) say their “participation in
the Bahá’í community makes a difference.”
At the same time, anecdotal reports
reveal areas for improvement. One young
organizer tells of going to a Local Spiritual
Assembly for advice. “Their response was,
like, ‘hand over your membership list and
your papers and step back. We’ll take it
from here.’ But that wasn’t my vision at all;
I was trying to create something that could
bring help to places nobody else can go.”
Fortunately for this project, its organizers
used the Assembly’s feedback to clarify their
objectives and streamline their methods.
When asked to say whether the statement
“At one time or another I have been
asked my opinion by an institution of the
Faith” is true or not, though 46 percent of
respondents say it is true or absolutely true,
another 28 percent say it is untrue, not at
all true, or “doesn’t apply to me.”
This percentage would seem to corroborate
the story told by the secretary of one
local assembly, who said when a group of
young Bahá’ís were asked to plan a community
activity, the assembly dismissed the
8 In Service to the Common Good
More than a
quarter of
respondents
say they have
not been asked
for an opinion
by Bahá’í
institutions.
resulting plan out of hand as “inappropriate”
after seeing the details, and especially the
youths’ choices in music. The secretary said
she regretted very much the dampening
effect this rejection had had on the youth.
What can adults do to support and
encourage youth more effectively?
Taking a cue from this last observation,
one solution might be to seek out and be
respectful of youths’ opinions and act on
their suggestions.
In her 1999 study A Tribe Apart,
Patricia Hersch concludes, after working
with a group of suburban Virginia teens
for six years, that the most important thing
adults in that community needed to do
was listen: “Listen
to the kids. Hear
what their lives are
like, what matters to
them, how things are
going in their world.
Listen and bring
adult wisdom to
the discussion.”
The world of
youth is different
from the adult world;
it needs to be taken on its own terms. This
should come as no surprise, since each
generational cohort experiences a “gap”
separating them from adults. Commenting
on teen music and culture, one writer noted,
“Every generation needs a private language
that people over 30 can’t translate.”3 And
as one of the teens in Hersch’s study put
it, “Kids don’t think the way adults think
they think.”
It is hard for today’s adults to understand
the world their children inhabit. Life
is much more complex than it once was.
Whereas communism and the atomic bomb
were among the major threats concerning
earlier generations, youth today have had
to come to terms with much more personal
and individual threats of danger and violence,
following the rise in school violence
and the proliferation of terrorism. The
demystification of celebrities and leaders
in all spheres has led to a heightened
awareness of issues of personal freedom
and privacy, as well as a keen sense of,
and aversion to hypocrisy. The advances in
communications and a proliferation of talk
and “reality” shows, in which ordinary people
can be “stars,” have helped to amplify
age-old American habits of individualism,
self-expression and self-promotion.
(American Demographics, 2001)
Young people may seem incomprehensible
to adults because of adults’ own
opinions of them. Barna found that 65-84
percent of teens think adults consider them
lazy, rude, sloppy and dishonest, while fewer
adults, in teens’ view, see their positive
attributes: friendly (63 percent), intelligent
(58 percent), trustworthy (36 percent),
hardworking (29 percent)
and spiritual (21 percent).
In contrast, Bahá’í
youth feel adults view
them positively: intelligent
and friendly (96 percent),
trustworthy (88 percent),
spiritual and interested
in making America a
better place (87 percent),
hardworking (86 percent). Most Bahá’í
youth disagree that adults see them as
dishonest (92 percent), rude (91 percent),
sloppy (83 percent) or lazy (80 percent).
Although adults love their children,
they seem to value their judgment less.
Teens say their parents have the greatest
influence on them and are the main sources
“Listen to the
kids. Hear what
their lives are
like, what matters
to them, how
things are going
in their world.
Listen and bring
adult wisdom to
the discussion.”
Bahá’í Youth in Their Own Words 9
Actively involved in charity
and service projects
Active in the
Bahá'í community
Tell friends about the faith
Pray daily
Beliefs shape my identity
One person can make
a difference
46%
45%
64%
64%
82%
74%
Bahá'í Youth
in their lives of “peace, trust,
power and safety,” Barna writes.
Teens also told Barna their parents
“were not as supportive as
they’d like regarding reactions
to the quality of the teens’ decision
making.” Hersch found that
“whatever behavior is common
to a group of kids feels normal
to them, whether it be doing
drugs or doing homework.
Whether the adult world sees
the lifestyle as positive or negative is not
the standard the kids are using.”
The experience of a Bahá’í mother who
accompanied her son and other volunteers
on an international project, points to a
different approach: “My role was to center
them, to ground them sometimes,
not tell them what to do. During
our daily consultations, when we
would review what had happened
the day before and plan our activities,
I would ask them questions
about the implications of what
they were deciding, about what
was likely to happen as a result
of a decision we were considering.”
Through a process of consultation that
brought in adult perspectives, this group,
like others interviewed, developed a learning
style that improved the quality of their
decision making, thereby contributing to
their effectiveness, safety and unity.
Hersch indicts the adults she studied
for concentrating on trying to control their
youth instead of channeling teens’ energies
into activities appropriate to their development.
“…it is easier to cancel events than
to figure out creative new ways of avoiding
dangers….What (teens) yearn for is to grow
and learn alongside each other with time
to socialize and space to adjust to their
rapidly changing selves….What students
don’t get…are enough real-life coping
skills….There are few popular age appropriate
events….Boys and girls want to be
together at this age, but society fails to
create enough safe developmental social
opportunities that catch on.”
Carol E. Lytch, in Choosing Church, her
study of Christian youth ministries, takes up a
similar theme. She says churches that attract
teens “get beyond the superficial solutions
to youth ministry and address teens’ deep
needs to belong, to believe, and to be
competent….Teens were attracted to high
goals, standards of excellence, demands
worthy of their attention and energy, and
rites of passage marking steps toward
adulthood.”
Or, as one young Bahá’í puts it, “Don’t
give (young Bahá’ís) two millions things to
do just because they have all this energy.”
These observations ring true within the
Bahá’í community as well. For many years,
young Bahá’ís around the country participated
in “Youth Workshops,” an activity
that focused on team building, performance
art and consciousness raising. When asked,
however, whether Youth Workshop has “had
a significant impact on my life,” 31 percent
said the statement was true or absolutely
true, while nearly one-third of respondents
said it “doesn’t apply to me” and 18 percent
10 In Service to the Common Good
Churches that
attract teens
“address teens’
deep needs to
belong, to
believe, and to
be competent”
said it was untrue or not at all true for
them. This type of youth program might
well be reaching the end of its life cycle.
Currently, many local Bahá’í groups
seek to involve their younger members
in the three “core activities” of devotional
gatherings, children’s classes and study
groups for adults and youth. Forty-one
percent of survey respondents say they
are “involved as much as
possible” in these core
activities, compared with
46 percent who say they are
very active in the community
overall; 8 percent say the
statement does not apply to
them, and 14 percent say the
statement is untrue for them.
In the context of organized service
programs, the skill sets developed through
the core activities are used by young volunteers
to meet a wide range of needs. Orien
Aid expects volunteers to have finished
the “Ruhi”
sequence of
courses, which
cover topics ranging
from Bahá’í
history and teachings
to children’s
education and
group problem
solving. Youth
involved in the Ark Project were called
upon, during their visits to the Yasothon
orphanage, to arrange a series of recreation
and instruction activities; their work
at home with Bahá'í children’s classes helped
prepare them to meet these needs. Insights
encourages participants to offer workshops
on topics that interest them, and to arrange
creative devotional periods throughout
their conferences.
The study group activity includes a
service component designed to encourage
participants to engage in activities that
reflect what they have learned through study.
Service, as shown above, is a powerful tool
for engaging youth; the core activities, as
well as programs that apply the same skills
in varied settings, may well be effective ways
to promote that sense of belief, belonging
and burgeoning competence
young people seek.
“Now Is the Time
for Service”
One young woman, reflecting
on her service, writes: “My inspiration
to serve is the principle
of the oneness of humanity
promoted by the Bahá’í writings. I believe
that everything I strive to do should be
toward the physical manifestation of this
spiritual principle.”
It is in the writings of ‘Abdu’l-Bahá
that we find these words: “Now is the
time for service, and for servitude unto the
Lord….Therefore must the friends of God
engender that tenderness which cometh
from Heaven, and bestow love in the spirit
upon all humankind. With every soul must
they deal according to the Divine counselings
and admonitions; to all must they
show forth kindness and good faith; to
all must they wish well. They must sacrifice
themselves for their friends, and wish
good fortune to their foes. They must
comfort the ill-natured, and treat their
oppressors with loving-kindness. They
must be as refreshing water to the thirsty,
and to the sick, a swift remedy, a healing
balm to those in pain and a solace to
every burdened heart.”
Bahá’í Youth in Their Own Words 11
What Can Adults Do
to Help Their Youth?
• Listen and consult:
the world of youth is
different from the adult
world, full of complexities
and tensions, and it needs
to be understood on its
own terms
• Concentrate on the
positive qualities in
young people
• Find creative activities that
are appropriate for each
age and stage of youths’
development, and that
are worthy of youths’
attention and energy
• Surrender the instinct to
control things; instead,
bring mature wisdom to
the situation to reduce
risks and allow young
people to develop
competencies
• Encourage and support
service programs of all
kinds; they help youth
cultivate their talents
and capacities
• Pray for young people
by name, every day.
“Don’t give
them two million
things to do
just because
they have all
this energy.”
“Orien Aid is really just about youth serving others,” says Samir Toloui, 21, one of the
organization’s founders. “Everything else is really only details of how youth can be connected
to an opportunity to share what they can do. We have an organization now, and a board
of directors, and we do fundraisers and plan trips, but mostly we want to help young people
like ourselves find ways of serving.”
Sam, as he prefers to be called, says the idea for Orien Aid came about after he had
been to the Maxwell International Bahá’í School in western Canada. “Everyone there was
from different countries, so you got an idea how interesting
people are, about some of the challenges they
face back home,” he says. “You got to appreciate the
differences in people, in their backgrounds, and you
got to make friends with them.”
One of those friends was Lua Anderson, a young
woman whose Canadian parents had been living for
several years in Rwanda, where they had started a
non-profit foundation. During a school vacation, Sam,
then 19, went to Rwanda to visit and fell in love with the
people and the place. Some time later, Lua’s father, Chris, sent an email to a number of
people, including Sam, asking if they could come to Rwanda and help build community
centers, teach classes in nutrition and hygiene and help construct a clinic in a rural area
outside Kigali, Rwanda’s capital.
Sam discussed the opportunity with a few friends; they decided to form a small group
and make a trip. “We started planning in January 2004,” recalls Steve Failows, one of those
Sam recruited early on, “and things just fell into place. By June, ten people went.”
Orien Aid was under way.
Part of the planning involved training. Orien worked with a firm
that specializes in development curricula to create easy-to-deliver
classes with a village perspective. The volunteers’ preparation
also included physical conditioning and familiarization with local
culture. Bahá’í participants were expected to have completed a
sequence of courses about the Bahá’í Faith, consultation, community
service and children’s education; these courses, in Orien’s
view, get volunteers ready, both practically and spiritually, for the tasks
they will do in the field.
“A lot of our friends thought we were crazy to go there,” Sam says. “There were
signs everywhere of the genocide but none of us really appreciated how big it was until
we got there. And we found these wonderful people, so sweet and open and loving, and
we fell in love with them. That’s why we go back. Orien made a five-year commitment to
Rwanda because we saw and heard of so many other organizations that go there once,
Orien Aid was founded
in 2003, and was incorporated
in the US as
a 501(c)(3) non-profit
organization in 2005.
Orien Aid was “created
to provide humanitarian
aid and socio-economic
development around
the world. We specialize
is finding, empowering,
and training youth to
get out there and change
the world.”
Program operations
include a five-year commitment,
in association
with the Joan Anderson
Memorial Foundation,
a Canadian NGO, in
Rwanda, and community
development projects in
Costa Rica.
More information
is available at
www.orienaid.org
PROFILE: Orien Aid
12 In Service to the Common Good
“The people are so wonderful, you want to do your best”
“We
wanted to
build relationships,
and we have.
That’s what keeps
us going back.”
give out a bunch of stuff to people and then leave. We didn’t
want to do that. We wanted to build relationships, and we
have. It’s those relationships, I’d say, and what we learn from
them, that keeps us all going back.”
Makini Boothe, a volunteer for Orien’s second summer
(2005) of operations in Rwanda, echoes Sam’s sentiments: “We
made a commitment to the people there, and every day we were
there was a fulfillment of our responsibility. If it was hard for me to get to
a place, driving in an old van for a couple of hours, I’d be inspired by the fact that it was
equally, if not more difficult for some who walked half a day to get
there. Everyone is so wonderful and their spirit encourages you to
want to put forth your best. Even if you’re tired or sick, you still know
you have to go and do what you’ve promised to do.”
For Makini, the work in Rwanda is about empowerment, which
she sees as an inherently spiritual process. “Many of my friends jokingly
ask me where I’m going next, insisting that they want to go next time.
They want to do what I do,” she says, “and wonder how it is that I
find opportunities—or even have the courage—to go to a place where
I literally don’t know a single person. When I tell them it’s because of
my religion, their response is always ‘Oh…religion.’ They want to get
involved in the material part of it—getting clean water into a village
or building a community center—but there’s this whole spiritual aspect that’s often more
difficult to recognize. But this is the most important part, because that’s where our energy
and commitment come from, and that’s what will keep the projects going after we leave.”
Orien’s volunteers have the freedom to pursue other opportunities that interest them.
Last year, for example, a group of youths who didn’t want to go to Rwanda, partly because
none of them spoke French, decided to accept an invitation to go to Costa Rica. The Spanishspeaking
group included Sam’s sister, Anisa. “She started asking me if Orien could do
something there,” Sam recalls, “and I’m like ‘Sure, why not? Just figure it out and do it.’”
So she did. In June 2005, nine volunteers trekked eight hours by bus and another three
on foot to the native Guaymí village of Progreso. “We stayed in raised houses and ate
beans and rice every day for every meal,” Anisa relates. “The family we were staying with
had started a school at their home, so some of the members of the group helped teach
those classes… Besides the classes there was a lot of work to be done: chopping wood,
building suspension bridges, helping restore and rebuild the community center, building
chairs and desks for another nearby school…The people of Progreso were all loving,
soft-spoken and have a wonderful culture of their own.”
Youths from Canada, the U.S., India, Iran, Japan, Singapore and Jamaica participated
in Orien’s 2005 projects in Rwanda and Costa Rica. By relying on the Bahá’í practice of
Bahá’í Youth in Their Own Words 13
“There’s
a whole spiritual
aspect that’s more
difficult to recognize…
that’s where our energy
and commitment
come from.”
consultation they learned to use their diversity as an advantage and make decisions as
a team.
Sometimes the volunteers incurred risks. Sam’s mother, Roya Toloui, had supported
Orien Aid from the beginning and in 2005 went to Rwanda. “I didn’t go as a
chaperone,” she says. “I went because the program and the service opportunity
interested me. I found that the young people were very special, they worked really
well together even when they disagreed about some things, but sometimes they
didn’t know their limits; they didn’t see the next steps, or the implications of what
they wanted to do.”
Roya tells a story that illustrates how youth and adults can support each other.
The group had committed to visit a remote village. The day of the trip, however,
their van broke down and some of the volunteers were not feeling well, but
there was no way to get word to the villagers and to those
who were walking a great distance to greet the visitors.
The group consulted about what to do.
Getting to the village would involve a long, tiring trip, but
some wanted to go anyway. “I was concerned that we were
stretching our resources too thin and I voiced my concern,”
Roya says. The group asked the opinion of an adult Rwandan.
“He is a wonderful man,” Roya says, “but he was very zealous.
He said, ‘If Bahá’u’lláh or ‘Abdu’l-Bahá were here, they would
go!’, and so of course the youth all felt moved to go, whatever the
risks. I obeyed the majority vote.”
The group set out, but one participant developed full-blown malaria—high fever,
vomiting—by the time they reached a remote village along their route. There was no
ready transportation back to Kigali and no clinic.
The travelers decided to split up. Making what provision they could for their sick
friend, some went on to their destination, and others waited with the sufferer, eventually
returning to the capital where they found a doctor and got treatment. “They learned
that actions and decisions have real consequences, and that plans don’t always work,”
Roya says. “They had to learn it themselves. Still, I saw they took some comfort having
someone present who had a little more experience.”
Orien Aid plans to continue to build for sustainability in Rwanda and possibly in
Costa Rica. The organization is committed to building trust with the local people by
returning to fulfill the commitments made. Orien also sponsors a young Rwandan’s
English studies in neighboring Uganda, where the schools are better and cheaper;
Orien hopes to sponsor additional students in time.
Orien is constantly searching for youth who want to serve. “We don’t have programs
yet for all the things youth can do,” says Sam Toloui. “If all the Bahá’í youth learn from
each other, spend more time creating positive energy, teaching, serving, and being a
positive influence on their friends—especially younger pre-teens—the world can change.”
14 In Service to the Common Good
Six of the Things
Orien Aid Does Well
• Erase boundaries using
technology and personal
communication
• Use consultation to
learn from even difficult
situations
• Recognize organization
limits and reach out to
others for resources—
training materials,
funding, advice
• Combine unique
strengths of both
youth and adults
• Emphasize sustainability
and trustworthiness
• Keep alert for new
opportunities; meet
them with initiative
“They learned
that actions and
decisions have
real consequences.
They had to learn it
themselves.”
Bahá’í Youth in Their Own Words 15
“She wanted to make an impact, and eradicate the stigma.”
Dale and Evan Ryan, sister and brother, have
traveled to Asia with their family many times;
they used to live there as
children. Starting in 2001,
their visits began to take on
another purpose: service.
As their mother
Maryanne tells the story,
“We let the Bahá’í community
know of our trips so we could be of
service while we were there.” The more
the family was in contact with local Bahá’í
communities—especially in Thailand—the
more the scope of their service grew.
Then, as Dale and Evan spoke with their
friends back in the U.S., interest in service in
Thailand increased. “That’s how the dance
workshop came up,” Maryanne recalls. In
2001, three youth traveled to Thailand. In
2002, the Ark Project was born, and has since
become a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization.
The volunteers were asked by a local
Bahá’í if they would perform at an AIDS
orphanage in the town of Yasothon. The
visit was not planned, but the group agreed
to go. “When we got there, one little boy
ran right up to Dale,” Maryanne relates. “He
had a fever, and was HIV-positive. She held
him for two hours that day.”
“Dale was really motivated to start
the project. There’s a big stigma there about
AIDS. She wanted to make more of an impact,
and eradicate the stigma. Now a lot of Thai
youth are going to the orphanage. She prayed
for this boy every night after coming back
to the States.” As of this writing, Dale is
volunteering for a year in Thailand.
In 2004, a group of eight—Dale and
Evan Ryan, and six of their friends—got
together and worked on a set of basic dances
to perform in Thailand. When they arrived in
one town, they learned that drugs were a big
problem there. The dance workshop showcased
their “drug dance,”
about the damaging effects
of substance abuse; local
children and youth watched
and learned the dance.
The project continues
and grows. Ten volunteers
went to Thailand and Japan during the
summer of 2005, under the auspices of
what is now known as the Karen Wallace
Service Project (KWSP), named in honor of
a Massachusetts Bahá’í and friend of the
Ryans who passed away in 2002.
Beyond their service overseas, some
of the volunteers are active at home. One
started a diversity club in her high school;
another is promoting mandatory drug testing
for athletes in his school.
This sort of organic growth creates its
own structure as it evolves. “We coordinated
a meeting at an annual youth conference in
2005. We met seven times altogether…and
there was a lot of dialogue, mostly over the
Internet, email and instant messaging. This
year’s ten youth were from our area (in New
Jersey), as well as Boston, Philadelphia,
Delaware, and Hoboken.”
In order to see long-lasting success, the
project has required support. Bahá’ís in the
youths’ home regions have helped with
strategy and preparation meetings, while
parents also support their own children
directly. Bahá’í institutions in the United States
and Thailand have helped with direction,
advice and logistical support. With this combination—
individual ideas and energy, and
the impetus lent by collective resources—
this project has connected with many individuals
around the world.
“One little boy had
a fever and was
HIV-positive…she held
him for two hours
that day.”
Five of the Things
KWSP and the Ark
Projects Do Well
• Be flexible enough to
follow new opportunities
as they arise
• Observe and listen in
order to identify those
new service needs
• Build a region-wide community
using technology
• Harmonize the contributions
of youth and adults
• Join passion, compassion
and commitment to
both international and
domestic goals
SNAPSHOT: KWSP/Ark Project
16 In Service to the Common Good
Insights, a virtual community for young
adults, is a different kind of service program:
rather than one group of people serving
others in some fashion, Insights participants
all serve each other.
Insights sponsors several conferences
a year. It is building a networked community
of interest via email, cell phone,
the Web and word of mouth.
A growing group of friends
and the coordinators of the
three national Bahá’í schools
worked together to bring more
than 100 participants to three conferences
in 2005.
Topics are chosen by young people
to meet their own needs, providing a way
to talk about hard challenges they face:
choosing a career, starting a marriage, having
children, arranging finances. Conferences are
loosely scheduled. Participants get to know
each other, relax and start new friendships.
In this way, they get advice from peers
who may have gone through similar experiences.
The conferences provide a structured
way for young adults to consult on how to
apply Bahá’í principles to life decisions.
Nevin Jenkins, one of the organizers,
explains Insights’ approach to prayerful
meditation during conferences. “We use
DVDs and PowerPoint presentations, incorporating
different styles—hip-hop, or multiple
languages. We encourage one person to take
on hosting devotions.” More than this,
however, the organizers recognize a need
to connect with God, even in the middle
of discussion. Nevin continues, “We don’t
just have devotions at the beginning of a
talk. We try to instill a devotional theme
into the whole conference. Sometimes we
stop and pray in the middle of a talk. Why
shouldn’t we draw on the power of the word
of God?”
Chiazor Igboechi, who attended the
first Insights conference, in 2004 at Louhelen
Bahá’í School in Michigan, recalls, “I’m
reminded how wonderful it is to be a Bahá’í
when I’m surrounded by 100 other Bahá’ís
who are warm, loving, and
sincere. Discovering that such
a religion existed, that it produced
such marvelous people,
was a very big part of why I
became a Bahá’í at the first
conference I attended.”
Dr. Rick Johnson, co-director of
Louhelen, believes that Insights has a lot of
potential. “It provides an opportunity for
young people,” he explains, “from teenagers
to individuals who are beginning to engage
career and family, to consider challenges
they face as they transition away from family,
or away from their college environment.”
One of the challenges faced by this
continuing project is finding a way to keep
participants connected after they leave a
conference. A virtual community is the organizers’
answer, but how that will work is still
evolving. Virginia Patterson-Nicely, originally
a participant, saw a need for consistent
administrative support to continue the effort,
so she volunteered. “I created a database
of young adults who filled out a questionnaire
at conferences. It contains personal
info, what they do for a living, and what they
can offer to Insights.”
“As word gets out,” Dr. Johnson says,
“we will see the numbers of participants
grow substantially. There’s a hunger among
young people, many of whom feel uprooted
from their homes and peer groups, to
experience community.”
“We try to instill
a devotional theme
into the whole
conference.”
Four of the Things
Insights Does Well
• Identify a need and meet
it, letting participants’
experience shape the
program
• Help people network and
share perspectives using
a mix of technology and
personal interaction
• Use devotional time
creatively
• Extend the community
virtually after the
conference ends
SNAPSHOT: Insights
“There’s a hunger among young people to experience community.”
Bahá’í Youth in Their Own Words 17
If a group of youth make a film about their
community, might they think differently
about that place? What if
those young people are
Navajo, already studying
spiritual development and
Navajo culture?
The Native American
Bahá’í Institute (NABI) in
Houck, Arizona, is asking questions like
these, exploring new possibilities for its
own role in the local community.
Activities for youth and elders such
as rug-weaving, the Moccasin Game, study
of Navajo language and spiritual development,
are already underway there. NABI staff
also visit reservation residents frequently,
carrying news and ideas to extended families
in their home compounds.
Starting in April, 2005, plans were
developed for an exciting pilot project: train
youth to film interviews with two renowned
Navajo artists—Chester Kahn, a sculptor,
painter and jewelry designer; and Knifewing
Segura, a police officer and kick-boxer turned
musician. For two weeks, the young people
researched and filmed the interviews, then
edited them into a feature that was shown
at a community gathering.
It was a learning experience. One
young man said, “You can spectate all you
want, but unless you check it out yourself,
you don’t know the whole story, you see?”
A young woman said, “Before this I might
have gone to the library. We had to go out
there and find answers. You all forced me
to do something I didn’t want to do, but I
liked doing it.” A staff member suggested,
“It took courage to do that.” “Yes, it did,”
the young woman agreed.
Craig Rothman, a project planner and
member of the National Spiritual
Assembly’s Media Services
Department, sees the program
as experiential education.
“If you can teach
youth something through
their own experience, they
retain the knowledge more
deeply than they are likely to do in a study
group,” he says. “Video was one tool. It
could have been anything, as long as it
involved the youths’ experience. They had
to learn to research, consult together, work
as a team. They saw their community as a
resource and a place that had a lot to offer
them. In the end, they produced a film
with heart, humanity and humor, and they
became stronger people.”
“I liked the parts best where we
would talk,” a participant says. “We talked
a lot! We had to decide what parts to put in,
and how to edit them.” Other participants
nodded in agreement when one said, “I
liked it when I got to use the camera. We
spoke with these people who I thought
would be different because they’re famous.
But first you learn about them and then
you get to interview them.”
The response to the film’s screening
was enthusiastic: The Chapter President,
a post similar to that of mayor, said he
planned to show the film to the Chapter
Council so they could see the positive things
young people are doing. Parents and grandparents
expressed —some tearfully—their
pride in the youths’ accomplishment.
Planning for more projects like this
one is underway.
“I liked it when I got to use the camera.”
“You can spectate all
you want, but unless
you check it out
yourself, you don’t
know the whole story”
Four of the Things
Media Training Pilot
Did Well
• Set a standard of
excellence
• Emphasized hands-on
learning
• Showed the community
as an asset for research
and learning
• Showed the youth as
asset to the community
SNAPSHOT: Media Training Pilot
18 In Service to the Common Good
Four of the Things
Umoja Souljahs
Do Well
• Emphasize participatory
learning
• Use consultation and
discussion to draw
lessons from hard topics
• Focus on creating a
constructive future
• Create a sense of
community and identity
Umoja, in Swahili, means unity. Souljah is
a play on the words soul and Jah—Swahili
for God. Put together, the
Umoja Souljahs are finding
ways of consecrating their
souls for God, in unity. For
nearly ten years, the Bahá’í
Unity Center in Decatur,
Georgia, has been home
to this group, oriented
to meeting the needs of
young black men of any
faith background, who live
in the neighborhood.
The basic needs of the
young men who live here
reflect the realities of life in a hard
environment: how to deal with the police,
for instance. One of the group’s founders
tells of being confronted by a police officer,
who told him to leave the restaurant
where he was having dinner. The young
man respectfully insisted on his right to
be there. Seeing that the officer was not
budging, however, he left peaceably, and
later wrote a letter about the incident to
the mayor and the chief of police. Within
days, a letter came back from the mayor
with apologies for the officer’s actions. The
young man says he tells this story to show
there are alternatives, and that sometimes
taking the peaceful route can produce a
greater effect.
Sharing stories like this, and others
drawn from African American history, lies
at the heart of the program, together with
the seven Kwanzaa principles and recreation
in the gym at the Bahá’í Unity Center. The
aim, according to Anthony Outler, the
group’s coordinator, is to help the young
men and boys answer two questions:
What does it mean to be a black man in
this society? Who are you,
given the experience of
black people in America?
Chris Inman, currently
studying accounting in
college, recalls, “It was
one of the greatest things
that ever happened to me.
As a kid in the inner city,
there aren’t too many influential
black males around.
The Unity Center was the
main place we could go,
especially Friday nights, to
play basketball. After that, we had this big
discussion on different topics—strong topics
that were crucial for my life.”
“Most of the guys, we still keep in
contact. They were some of my best friends
and we are still strong. We are still the same
type of people.”
Lawrence Ivory, 13, says, “I’ve learned
about the past, about slavery, and about
the Negro. I’ve learned some of the quotes
that Malcolm X was saying about slave
history. I’ve learned how to think critically,
and many more things.”
What’s next? “Our dream is to turn
this into a school for young black men,”
says Anthony Outler. “When we look at
the number of black men incarcerated,
disenfranchised, or involved with drugs,
the numbers are staggering. Many people
have marches or empowerment programs,
but they can only take the black community
so far. They don’t have the teachings of
Bahá’u’lláh. Bahá’u’lláh says we should be
‘a defender of the victim of oppression.’ ”
The Seven
Kwanzaa Principles
1. Umoja (Unity)
2. Kujichagulia
(Self Determination)
3. Ujima (Collective
Work & Responsibility)
4. Ujamaa (Cooperative
Economics)
5. Nia (Purpose)
6. Kuumba (Creativity)
7. Imani (Faith)
SNAPSHOT: Umoja Souljahs
“We had this big discussion on different topics, strong topics
that were crucial for my life.”
References
Barna, G. (2001). Real Teens. Ventura, California; Regal Books.
CBS News (2004). The Echo Boomers. 60 Minutes.
Retrieved from http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2004/10/01/60minutes/main646890.shtml.
Friedman, T.L. (2005). The World Is Flat. New York, New York; Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Getting Inside Generation Y (2001). American Demographics. Media Central, Inc.
Retrieved from http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m4021/is_2001_Sept_1/ai_78426787.
Hersch, P. (1999). A Tribe Apart. New York, New York; Random House.
In Service to the Common Good (2004). Wilmette, Illinois; The National Spiritual Assembly
of the Bahá’ís of the United States/Office of Development Research
Lyons-Cavazos, M. (2004). Echo Boomers Flex Their “Muscle” with Success of Napster:
What does the success of Napster say about this generation of youth? Cheskin, Inc.
Retrieved from http://www.cheskin.com/p/ar.asp?mlid=7&arid=20&art=1.
Lytch, C.E. (2004). Choosing Church. Louisville, Kentucky; Westminster John Knox Press.
End Notes
1 Statistics are drawn from the 2005 survey of Bahá'í youth, which 1,029 young people completed
online or over the phone. All statistics cited refer to this set of respondents. Several
of the questions were formatted on a 1-to-10 scale; particular attention was paid to what are
termed the "upper" and "lower" boxes, comprising the three highest and lowest choices.
2 Local Spiritual Assemblies are elected each year from among all Bahá’ís 21 years of age or
older living in the locality. These volunteers—there is no clergy in the Bahá’í Faith—administer
the affairs of the local Bahá’í community.
3 John Weir, “Hot Sound”, from Rolling Stone, 8/97; quoted in Barna, 27.
Copyright © 2005 National Spiritual Assembly of the Bahá’ís of the United States. All rights reserved.
Drawing by: Henry Becton Warren
Bahá’í National Center
1233 Central Street
Evanston, IL 60201-1611
USA
www.bahaiyouth.org
www.us.bahai.org
1-800-22-UNITE

Friday, July 13, 2007

In Service


to the Common Good







Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress In Service to the Common Good




PREFACE



We commend this third publication in the In Service series to the thoughtful attention of the participants in the 2006 Social and Economic Development Conference, sponsored by the Rabbani Charitable Trust.






You, the practitioners and students of development, are committed to advancing the prosperity and well-being of all people, to promoting human dignity and to achieving that “dynamic coherence between the spiritual and practical requirements of life on earth” that will, ultimately, bring forth peace and happiness from out of the turbulence of our times.






The pages that follow project the experience of your peers against the backdrop of the great social forces that are impelling mankind toward the destined realization of its oneness. The analysis here seeks to describe the extent to which the work of these Bahá’ís is aligned with, and reinforced by, those same forces, even as the youth and adults who appear in these pages share what they are learning about the application of spiritual principle and practical wisdom to the challenges they have taken on.
For those who encounter the development work of the Bahá’í community for the first time, we offer this document, and the series of which it forms a part, as an affirmation of our partnership with you in this important endeavor.











To all who read this booklet, we acknowledge that the work you have undertaken brings more than its share of difficulties and frustrations—indeed, the Bahá’í writings describe this as the Age of Frustration.




We trust, therefore, that the reflections gathered here will provide a measure of encouragement, because although the scope of your projects may at times seem small, the forces arrayed around you multiply the effects of your exertions, just as certain musical notes, when struck, ring with a resonance that excites the heart of even a distant listener.





THE NATIONAL SPIRITUAL ASSEMBLY OF THE BAHÁ’ÍS OF THE UNITED STATES December 2006





In Service to the Common Good





In Service to the Common Good
Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress








1 ALIGNING DEVELOPMENT WITH THE FORCES OF PROGRESS “












The proclamation of the Oneness of Mankindimplies at once a warning and a promise—a warning that in it lies the sole means for the salvation of a greatly suffering world, a promise that its realization is at hand…
It has…come at last to be regarded…not only as an approaching possibility, but as the necessary outcome of the forces now operating in the world.” ~The Bahá’í Writings In Service to the Common Good Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress
1 ALIGNING DEVELOPMENT WITH THE FORCES OF PROGRESS
“The proclamation of the Oneness of Mankind…implies at once a warning and a promise—a warning that in it lies the sole means for the salvation of a greatly suffering world, a promise that its realization is at hand…(I)t has…come at last to be regarded…not only as an approaching possibility, but as the necessary outcome of the forces now operating in the world.” ~The Bahá’í Writings In the last fifty years, the governments of the Western industrialized nations have spent $2.3 trillion on foreign aid1 to try to end poverty and disease, build infrastructure, promote literacy, enlarge the scope and capacities of grass roots organizations, and foster better governance. Likewise, scores of public and private institutions have invested substantial resources. World Vision, for example, spent $752 million on its programs in 2005. The Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria has awarded nearly $5 billion in grants, disbursing $2.8 billion of that money in just the last four years. Despite these huge investments, success has been sporadic at best. Multilateral agencies and the private sector have set appealing goals but have been unable to reach them. Specific actions and the sacri-fices of many of those involved have been impressive, but poverty and disease still claim countless victims hourly. Infrastructure decay in many countries makes development nearly impossible. Organizations of and for the disadvantaged find their progress blocked by governments that know neither shame nor constraint on their rapacious behavior. A growing number of organizations have focused their attention on community based programs, but the proliferation of different models and approaches has so fractionalized the work that neither strategic coherence nor momentum can be realized. Some economists have turned to statistical analysis and opinion research to try to find ways of assessing the comparative merits of various interventions. This research is clarifying important questions, but the essential assumption, that material well-being is the only feasible goal, is rarely challenged. A wider perspective on development must connect work in the field with the vast changes taking place at the foundations of the current social order: A growing sense of global solidarity, and a search for models that integrate moral values with the achievement of material benefits, signal an awareness that all people, members of a single human family, are now ready and able to take responsibility for their own material and spiritual advancement. It is this perspective that informs the development work of Bahá’ís. During these same fifty years, the global Bahá’í community has painstakingly constructed an administrative network that extends from the World Center of the Faith in Haifa, Israel to more than 116,000 localities throughout the world. Using a process of experimentation and reflection, Bahá’ís are learning from their successes, setbacks and mistakes to enhance the quality of life of those in a community, often working in close collaboration with like-minded partners. Underlying Bahá’ís’ commitment to their work is the belief that the divine intent for this era of mankind’s history is the accomplishment of peace, justice, and spiritual and material prosperity for everyone. The following report looks at certain aspects of present day development theory and practice; seeks, through a brief review of current scholarship and Bahá’í writings, to find glimpses of that larger perspective; and examines how the motives, principles and methods Bahá’ís apply in their service align with the forces shaping society to achieve “a dynamic coherence between the spiritual and practical requirements of life on earth.”2 In the last fifty years, the governments of the Western industrialized nations have spent $2.3 trillion on foreign aid1 to try to end poverty and disease, build infrastructure, promote literacy, enlarge the scope and capacities of grass roots organizations, and foster better governance. Likewise, scores of public and private institutions have invested substantial resources. World Vision, for example, spent $752 million on its programs in 2005. The Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria has awarded nearly $5 billion in grants, disbursing $2.8 billion of that money in just the last four years. Despite these huge investments, success has been sporadic at best. Multilateral agencies and the private sector have set appealing goals but have been unable to reach them. Specific actions and the sacri-fices of many of those involved have been impressive, but poverty and disease still claim countless victims hourly. Infrastructure decay in many countries makes development nearly impossible. Organizations of and for the disadvantaged find their progress blocked by governments that know neither shame nor constraint on their rapacious behavior. A growing number of organizations have focused their attention on community based programs, but the proliferation of different models and approaches has so fractionalized the work that neither strategic coherence nor momentum can be realized. Some economists have turned to statistical analysis and opinion research to try to find ways of assessing the comparative merits of various interventions. This research is clarifying important questions, but the essential assumption, that material well-being is the only feasible goal, is rarely challenged. A wider perspective on development must connect work in the field with the vast changes taking place at the foundations of the current social order: A growing sense of global solidarity, and a search for models that integrate moral values with the achievement of material benefits, signal an awareness that all people, members of a single human family, are now ready and able to take responsibility for their own material and spiritual advancement. It is this perspective that informs the development work of Bahá’ís. During these same fifty years, the global Bahá’í community has painstakingly constructed an administrative network that extends from the World Center of the Faith in Haifa, Israel to more than 116,000 localities throughout the world. Using a process of experimentation and reflection, Bahá’ís are learning from their successes, setbacks and mistakes to enhance the quality of life of those in a community, often working in close collaboration with like-minded partners. Underlying Bahá’ís’ commitment to their work is the belief that the divine intent for this era of mankind’s history is the accomplishment of peace, justice, and spiritual and material prosperity for everyone. The following report looks at certain aspects of present day development theory and practice; seeks, through a brief review of current scholarship and Bahá’í writings, to find glimpses of that larger perspective; and examines how the motives, principles and methods Bahá’ís apply in their service align with the forces shaping society to achieve “a dynamic coherence between the spiritual and practical requirements of life on earth.”2 2
In Service to the Common Good
Current Issues in Development
A central issue in development today is whether it A persuasive case can be made that grand is working. After spending more than $2 trillion on gestures, however well or nobly conceived, do not aid (including military outlays), or nearly $50 billion work, in part because they consistently fall prey to yearly for the last five decades, it is reasonable divisive political processes. The Millennium Develop-to ask what progress has been made toward the ment Goals (MDGs), adopted with great fanfare in stated goals of the development endeavor. 2000, are merely the latest in a series of such global
No clear answers emerge to this controversial plans: A UN summit in 1990 set the goal of 2000 for question. One study3 analyzed per capita income universal primary-school enrollments; a summit in 1977 growth and inflation and found that countries called for universal access to clean water and sani
with the highest number of World tation by 1990. Both deadlines have Bank and IMF “structural adjustment loans” tended to have Despite continued investment and been extended to 2015 to coincide with the MDGs. Such plans are low or negative growth and high sacrifice, three attractive, and they have produced inflation. Niger received 14 billion people still some successes—the eradication adjustment loans between 1980 live on less than two of small pox, for example, in sup-and 1999, and experienced a 2.3 percent negative growth rate for the period and an average infladollars a day; nearly a billion are still hungry; and one billion adults are port of which there was remarkable unity of purpose. But despite the continued investment of enormous tion rate of 2 percent. Ghana had still illiterate. resources, an estimated three 26 loans, a 1.2 percent growth billion people still live on less than rate and 32 percent inflation. two dollars a day, adjusted for
Ukraine, which had ten loans, has seen its purchasing power; nearly a billion are still hungry; personal incomes drop 8.4 percent and inflation and one billion adults are still illiterate.5 soar to a yearly average of 215 percent. A better approach, many observers suggest,
Other studies, using these and other meas-is to promote grass roots initiatives with realistic ures, reach different conclusions, or frame the goals and accountability to ensure that those question differently. Research on social choice affected can themselves gauge programs’ success. and development economics, for example, goes But is this strategy an improvement? beyond the metrics of incomes and economic To answer this question, some practitioners trends to examine indices of human freedom. have introduced randomized studies that use The researchers recognize that people need to surveys, control groups and statistical tests to have a voice and real choices regarding decisions shed light on common assumptions and assess that shape economic outcomes.4 The United the relative merits of various kinds of inputs. Nations Development Programme’s “human A study on efforts to combat HIV/AIDS in development index” is another advance, although Kenya, for example, examined the comparative indicators are still needed that capture the subtle efficacy of three intervention strategies: teacher moral and social determinants of collective life. training, student debates on the benefits of con-Development outcomes, however, by these or dom use, and increased funding to reduce school any measure have been disappointing. drop-outs. The study tracked teen pregnancies,
Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress
which are associated with unprotected sex; self-reported condom use and sexual activity; and drop-out rates, since longer school attendance has been shown to decrease the incidence of high-risk behaviors. Researchers found that “after two years, girls in schools where teachers had been trained were more likely to be married in the event of a pregnancy, but the teacher training program,” in which most teachers participated diligently, “had little other impact on students’ knowledge, attitudes, and behavior, or on the incidence of teen childbearing. The condom debates and essays increased practical knowl-edge and self-reported use of condoms without increasing self-reported sexual activity. Reducing the cost of education by paying for school uni-forms reduced drop-out rates, teen marriage, and childbearing.”6 Some interventions, in other words, affect only specific behaviors. The larger point of this study, though, is that it is possible to unbundle the effects of different approaches, measure their impact and gain a fuller under-standing of the processes at work. Another puzzle for program designers and field workers alike has to do with improving the quality of village health care. Interventions are designed to bring more qualified health care providers into villages, to increase their atten-dance at village clinics, to build more and better clinics, and to reduce the cost of medicines, among other goals. A randomized study which looked at health care delivery in rural India, however, reported that “Villagers’ health is poor despite the fact that they heavily use health care facilities and spend a lot on health care.” “The quality of the public service is abysmal,” the report continues, “and unregulated and private providers who are often unqualified provide the bulk of health care in the area… Controlling for age, gender, distance from a road, and per capita monthly expenditures, lung capacity and body mass index are lower where the facilities are worse.” Here was the surprise, however: “(V)illagers seem pretty content with what they are getting. 81 percent report that their last visit to a private facility made them feel better, and 75 percent report that their last visit to a public facility made them feel better. Self reported health and well-being measures… appear to be uncorrelated with the quality of the public facilities. The quality of the health services may impact health but does not seem to impact people’s perception of their own health or the health care they are getting, perhaps because they have come to expect very little. Improving the quality of health care in an environment where the clients themselves are not particularly inter-ested in complaining about (the care) they are getting, will not be easy.”7 Sustainability, a key development goal, was shown in another study to have its limits. Local attitudes and perceptions were undermining a program aimed at getting de-worming drugs into the hands of villagers in Kenya. The randomized 4
In Service to the Common Good
study revealed that despite efforts to educate parents and schoolchildren on worm prevention, which requires twice-yearly medication for life, the populace were not persuaded to take the necessary drugs if they had to buy them. The study concludes that “the pursuit of sustainability may be an illusion, and that in the short-run, at least, external subsidies will remain necessary.”8 Working through community based or grass roots organizations often appears to be a more successful approach than attempts to impose change from the outside. “Foreign donors are increasingly funding local community organizations for the poor and disad-vantaged in developing countries (Smillie and Helmich, 1999),” reports an April 2004 working paper documenting another randomized study. “For example, from 1996 to 2003, World Bank funding for community-driven development increased from $700 million to $2 billion.” This quantitative analysis attempted to test the intuitively appealing proposition that “… organizations of the disadvantaged create positive externalities, and in particular strengthen the position of these groups in society. A natural inference is that these organizations should be subsidized.” Researchers evaluating a program to strengthen rural women’s groups in western Kenya, though, discovered what they dubbed the “Rockefeller Effect:” “(T)he program did not improve group strength or functioning as meas-ured by participation rates, assistance to members, and assistance to other community projects. The funding did, however, change the very character-istics of the groups that made them attractive to funders in the first place. Younger, more educated women and women employed in the formal sector joined the groups, and men and better-educated and wealthier women moved into key leadership positions.”9 At a minimum, then, donors who wish to support community based groups should, based on this research, plan for the changes that increased outside funding can introduce. Additional studies of this kind may prove valuable in discovering more effective approaches to improving the quality of life of disadvantaged populations. Paradoxically, while none can “deny that the long-term results of development projects have been heartbreakingly disappointing in their failure to close the yawning gap between the rich and the poor”, encouragement can nonetheless be found in the “sense of common humanity in (development) objec-tives that spoke perhaps most eloquently in the response (humanitarian initiatives) evoked from an army of idealistic youth of many lands.”10 Despite pouring a wealth of resources into programs of all kinds, and despite the important learning that has occurred, development institu-tions and practitioners have yet to evolve a systemic understanding of the problems to be solved. In the absence of such an understanding, interventions serve as piecemeal improvisations at best and local advances seem insignificant in the face of such enormous problems. “Something must be done; anything must be done, whether it works or not,” said one prominent aid fund-raiser in a statement “born of frustration and the instinctive knowledge that we cannot simply stand by and watch this horror and expect to be unchanged by our inaction.”11










But people deserve better. In a world where terror and extremism feed on mankind’s despair,










the stakes have never been higher, the need to “get it right” never greater. Encouragement can be found in the sense of common humanity underlying development initiatives. study revealed that despite efforts to educate parents and schoolchildren on worm prevention, which requires twice-yearly medication for life, the populace were not persuaded to take the necessary drugs if they had to buy them. The study concludes that “the pursuit of sustainability may be an illusion, and that in the short-run, at least, external subsidies will remain necessary.”8 Working through community based or grass roots organizations often appears to be a more successful approach than attempts to impose change from the outside. “Foreign donors are increasingly funding local community organizations for the poor and disad-vantaged in developing countries (Smillie and Helmich, 1999),” reports an April 2004 working paper documenting another randomized study. “For example, from 1996 to 2003, World Bank funding for community-driven development increased from $700 million to $2 billion.” This quantitative analysis attempted to test the intuitively appealing proposition that “… organizations of the disadvantaged create positive externalities, and in particular strengthen the position of these groups in society. A natural inference is that these organizations should be subsidized.” Researchers evaluating a program to strengthen rural women’s groups in western Kenya, though, discovered what they dubbed the “Rockefeller Effect:” “(T)he program did not improve group strength or functioning as meas-ured by participation rates, assistance to members, and assistance to other community projects. The funding did, however, change the very character-istics of the groups that made them attractive to funders in the first place. Younger, more educated women and women employed in the formal sector joined the groups, and men and better-educated and wealthier women moved into key leadership positions.”9 At a minimum, then, donors who wish to support community based groups should, based on this research, plan for the changes that increased outside funding can introduce. Additional studies of this kind may prove valuable in discovering more effective approaches to improving the quality of life of disadvantaged populations. Paradoxically, while none can “deny that the long-term results of development projects have been heartbreakingly disappointing in their failure to close the yawning gap between the rich and the poor”, encouragement can nonetheless be found in the “sense of common humanity in (development) objec-tives that spoke perhaps most eloquently in the response (humanitarian initiatives) evoked from an army of idealistic youth of many lands.”10 Despite pouring a wealth of resources into programs of all kinds, and despite the important learning that has occurred, development institu-tions and practitioners have yet to evolve a systemic understanding of the problems to be solved. In the absence of such an understanding, interventions serve as piecemeal improvisations at best and local advances seem insignificant in the face of such enormous problems. “Something must be done; anything must be done, whether it works or not,” said one prominent aid fund-raiser in a statement “born of frustration and the instinctive knowledge that we cannot simply stand by and watch this horror and expect to be unchanged by our inaction.”11 But people deserve better. In a world where terror and extremism feed on mankind’s despair, the stakes have never been higher, the need to “get it right” never greater. Encouragement can be found in the sense of common humanity underlying development initiatives. Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress
5
Toward a Larger Perspective
What must be recognized is that the foundations on which society has long been based are shifting; society is today in a state mathematicians Development and the call “far from equilibrium,” where old laws no Tipping Point longer apply and new forms of organization and
Most Bahá’í projects are still small in
social adaptation re-arrange themselves with
scale, but their potential, in a world
startling speed. Gaining a better perspective on
far from equilibrium, should not be
development requires an understanding of the
underestimated.
shift under way; awareness of the underlying forces at work makes possible the creation of
“(N)onlinear events can have effects
new models that are more likely to address both
disproportionate to their causes...
the root causes of poverty, disease and injustice,
the dynamic interactions among
and their symptoms, so tragically evident in the
individual elements of the system
daily lives of millions of people.
generate global events that require
Seventy years ago, the Bahá’í writings de-
a holistic description, which cannot
scribed this new social reality that, as it emerges, upsets the world’s equilibrium: “Unification of be reduced to an account of the the whole of mankind is the hallmark of the individual elements. …(A)t the tip-stage which human society is now approaching. ping point, the effect of individual Unity of family, of tribe, of city-state, and nation events is unpredictable…it is never have been successively attempted and fully estab-possible to be sure which particular lished. World unity is the goal towards which a
grain of sand will tip the balance.
harassed humanity is striving. Nation-building
(Moment of Complexity, 149)
has come to an end. The anarchy inherent in state sovereignty is moving towards a climax.”
“As networks become more hetero-
Just as society can see “the marvelous
geneous and interconnected, they
progress achieved in the realm of physical science,
begin to act as a whole in surprising
by the world-wide expansion of commerce and
ways. What distinguishes the current
industry,” which has “contracted and transformed
moment of complexity is the emer
the world into a single highly complex organism,”
gence of a network culture that is
it also sees the many threats to its well-being: the
truly global… ‘Like it or not, some
persistence of age-old animosities between nations
form of global civilization will emerge.
and the threat of terrorism; an extraordinary rise
We are at that particular time in
in organized crime and violence; swelling numbers of the displaced; a widening economic divide history when population, technology, between the rich and the poor; the indiscriminate economics, and knowledge spin us exploitation of natural resources; and a relentless together.’” (ibid., 194) pursuit of material goods and benefits that crowd out human values such as happiness, fidelity, love.12
In Service to the Common Good
Bahá’ís see the often painful “simultaneous processes of rise and of fall” as conducive to the next and final stage in mankind’s social evolution. Integration and disintegration, order and chaos, “with their continuous and reciprocal reactions on each other, are but aspects of a greater Plan, one and indivisible, whose Source is God, whose author is Bahá’u’lláh,13 the theater of whose operations is the entire planet, and whose ultimate objectives are the unity of the human race and the peace of all mankind.” Even if one rejects the premise of divine involvement in today’s turbulent scene, it cannot be denied that a growing sense of world solidarity is evident in the grass roots response of people, who, galvanized by a vision of a new global order, have created “countless movements and organizations of social change at local, regional, and international levels.” The “urgent advocacy of organizations supported by growing numbers in every part of the globe” can be seen in the areas of “human rights, the advance of women, the social requirements of sustainable economic development, the overcoming of prejudices, the moral education of children, literacy, primary health care, and a host of other vital concerns.”14 To Bahá’ís, these advances represent a spiritual response to the challenges of the age in which we live. Indeed, history has shown that religion has been perhaps the most potent force for change, whether for good or ill. Conversely, the lack of religion, according to the Bahá’í writings, is partly responsible for the world’s current trou-bles: “[When] the light of religion is quenched in men’s hearts… a deplorable decline in the for-tunes of humanity immediately sets in, bringing in its wake all the evils which a wayward soul is capable of revealing…. Human character is debased, confidence is shaken, the nerves of discipline are relaxed, the voice of human conscience is stilled, the sense of decency and shame is obscured, conceptions of duty, of solidarity, of reciprocity and loyalty are distorted, and the very feeling of peacefulness, of joy and of hope is gradually extinguished.” Linking religion and development may seem to raise the specter of ideological or doctrinal conflict. And although there is an element of truth in the argument that spiritual and moral issues, because of their potential for discord, should remain outside the framework of development, setting such issues aside has had the effect of delivering “the shaping of humanity’s future into the hands of a new orthodoxy, one which argues that truth is amoral and facts are independent of values.” This orthodoxy has its own set of assumptions, which are “essentially materialistic. That is to say, the purpose of development is defined in terms of the successful cultivation in all societies of those means for the achievement of material prosperity that have, through trial and error, already come to characterize certain regions of the world. Modifications in develop-ment discourse do indeed occur, accommodating differences of culture and political system and responding to the alarming dangers posed by environmental degradation. Yet the underlying materialistic assumptions remain essentially unchallenged.”15 The alternative to equating materialism with prosperity is to give due regard to religious Bahá’ís see the often painful “simultaneous processes of rise and of fall” as conducive to the next and final stage in mankind’s social evolution. Integration and disintegration, order and chaos, “with their continuous and reciprocal reactions on each other, are but aspects of a greater Plan, one and indivisible, whose Source is God, whose author is Bahá’u’lláh,13 the theater of whose operations is the entire planet, and whose ultimate objectives are the unity of the human race and the peace of all mankind.” Even if one rejects the premise of divine involvement in today’s turbulent scene, it cannot be denied that a growing sense of world solidarity is evident in the grass roots response of people, who, galvanized by a vision of a new global order, have created “countless movements and organizations of social change at local, regional, and international levels.” The “urgent advocacy of organizations supported by growing numbers in every part of the globe” can be seen in the areas of “human rights, the advance of women, the social requirements of sustainable economic development, the overcoming of prejudices, the moral education of children, literacy, primary health care, and a host of other vital concerns.”14 To Bahá’ís, these advances represent a spiritual response to the challenges of the age in which we live. Indeed, history has shown that religion has been perhaps the most potent force for change, whether for good or ill. Conversely, the lack of religion, according to the Bahá’í writings, is partly responsible for the world’s current trou-bles: “[When] the light of religion is quenched in men’s hearts… a deplorable decline in the for-tunes of humanity immediately sets in, bringing in its wake all the evils which a wayward soul is capable of revealing…. Human character is debased, confidence is shaken, the nerves of discipline are relaxed, the voice of human conscience is stilled, the sense of decency and shame is obscured, conceptions of duty, of solidarity, of reciprocity and loyalty are distorted, and the very feeling of peacefulness, of joy and of hope is gradually extinguished.” Linking religion and development may seem to raise the specter of ideological or doctrinal conflict. And although there is an element of truth in the argument that spiritual and moral issues, because of their potential for discord, should remain outside the framework of development, setting such issues aside has had the effect of delivering “the shaping of humanity’s future into the hands of a new orthodoxy, one which argues that truth is amoral and facts are independent of values.” This orthodoxy has its own set of assumptions, which are “essentially materialistic. That is to say, the purpose of development is defined in terms of the successful cultivation in all societies of those means for the achievement of material prosperity that have, through trial and error, already come to characterize certain regions of the world. Modifications in develop-ment discourse do indeed occur, accommodating differences of culture and political system and responding to the alarming dangers posed by environmental degradation. Yet the underlying materialistic assumptions remain essentially unchallenged.”15 The alternative to equating materialism with prosperity is to give due regard to religious Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress
7
Rural Development in Zambia
“We never asked them if they wanted our kind of program,” the local worker for a Zambian non-governmental organization (NGO) said. “When you have a hammer, everything looks like a nail. We brought our hammer to the villages, but we’ve spent a huge amount of time trying to get them to use it and they don’t.”
Trust turns out to be the missing bedrock value. The program should work: It is logical; everyone has seen family incomes increase; the incentives all point in the right direction; and the NGO has an expert, dedicated staff.
But the dominant families in the area also make up the cooperative boards and run the co-ops for their own benefit. The farmers know this, so they don’t buy co-op shares or pay dues, and many of them never come to meetings. This is not laziness or ignorance; it is rational economic behavior on the farmers’ part.
As a result, the NGO is now devoting more attention to building trust as a complement to its skills training.


























teachings, which have taught people “to make small and relatively diminishing minority of the great sacrifices for the common good, to practice world’s inhabitants from the poverty experienced forgiveness, generosity, and trust, to use wealth by the vast majority of the globe’s population.”17 and other resources in ways that serve the advance-It is highly encouraging to note that the World ment of civilization. Institutional systems have Bank, recognizing that religion and religious organ-been devised to translate these moral advances izations have a role to play in development, has into the norms of social life on a vast scale.”16 created the Development Dialogue on Values
Perhaps it is not too great a leap to see and Ethics, whose stated purpose is “exploring the setbacks to many development initiatives a more ‘comprehensive,’ ‘holistic,’ and ‘integrated’ as resulting from a lack of trust, forgiveness and vision of development.” Other individuals and generosity, and to see an antidote in cultivating organizations also are striving to implement such moral qualities as the capacity and willing-“integrated models” that “incorporate the ness to sacrifice for the common good. Given multiple dimensions (biological, psychosocial the limited benefits development has yielded, it and spiritual) of human nature.”18 is “no longer possible to maintain the belief that Bahá'ís believe that development, at its the approach to social and economic development deepest level, is about applying the principle to which the materialistic conception of life has of the oneness of mankind to improve people’s given rise is capable of meeting humanity’s needs. physical well-being, access to education and Optimistic forecasts about the changes it would the means of generating wealth, while at the generate have vanished into the ever-widening same time upholding their dignity as cherished abyss that separates the living standards of a members of one human family.
In Service to the Common Good
Historically, this has not been the case. The masses of humanity have been “seen not as protagonists but essentially as objects of the… much vaunted civilizing process. Despite benefits conferred on a minority among them, the colonial peoples existed chiefly to be acted upon—to be used, trained, exploited, Christianized, civilized, mobilized—as the shifting agendas of Western powers dictated.”19 This dynamic still exists. For example, in a 2004 National Public Radio report, residents of northern Nigeria said they refused to be victims of an agenda that favored the “disease of the moment in New York.” In this case, that disease was polio, which the World Health Organization wanted to eradicate in Nigeria through inocula-tions. The issue, the Nigerians said, was that malaria and measles, not polio, were killing their children. As one experienced development practitioner notes, the problem with eradicating disease is that it “requires getting every last case and of course a village in Nigeria does not see this as a priority if nobody has the disease. The problem is failing to believe that people in a village could understand this if they were seen as partners, not just as subjects to be vaccinated.” Similarly, Cameroonian journalist Jean-Claude Shanda Tonme wrote that “it was not for us, for Africa,” that the musicians at a 2005 Live 8 “End Poverty in Africa” fund raising concert were singing. “It was to amuse the crowds and to clear their own consciences,” Tonme said. “They still believe us to be like children that they must save, as if we don’t realize ourselves what the source of our problems is.”20 But “Bahá’u’lláh has come to free humanity from this long bondage, and the closing decades of the twentieth century were devoted by the community of His followers to creative experimen-tation with the means by which His objective can be realized.”21 Fidelity to the principle of oneness implies that the masses of mankind are ready and worthy of assuming their proper role as protagonists in their own development, rather than spectators looking on from a distance. This larger perspective is making some headway. One example can be found in recent news: The Norwegian Nobel Committee, in awarding the 2006 Peace Prize to Muhammad Yunus, founder of the Grameen Bank, declared, “Every single individual on earth has both the potential and the right to live a decent life… even the poorest of the poor can work to bring about their own development…. Development from below also serves to advance democracy and human rights.”22 If it can be accepted that the spirit of the age is moving mankind, consciously or not, toward the oneness of humanity and that this dynamic involves mobilizing the spiritual strength of each person, then it follows that approaches which ignore or resist this tectonic societal shift must, sooner or later, fail. On the other hand, approaches aligned with the social and spiritual reality of our time must eventually prosper and produce lasting results. The Bahá’í experience in devel-opment illustrates an attempt to achieve such an alignment. Historically, this has not been the case. The masses of humanity have been “seen not as protagonists but essentially as objects of the… much vaunted civilizing process. Despite benefits conferred on a minority among them, the colonial peoples existed chiefly to be acted upon—to be used, trained, exploited, Christianized, civilized, mobilized—as the shifting agendas of Western powers dictated.”19 This dynamic still exists. For example, in a 2004 National Public Radio report, residents of northern Nigeria said they refused to be victims of an agenda that favored the “disease of the moment in New York.” In this case, that disease was polio, which the World Health Organization wanted to eradicate in Nigeria through inocula-tions. The issue, the Nigerians said, was that malaria and measles, not polio, were killing their children. As one experienced development practitioner notes, the problem with eradicating disease is that it “requires getting every last case and of course a village in Nigeria does not see this as a priority if nobody has the disease. The problem is failing to believe that people in a village could understand this if they were seen as partners, not just as subjects to be vaccinated.” Similarly, Cameroonian journalist Jean-Claude Shanda Tonme wrote that “it was not for us, for Africa,” that the musicians at a 2005 Live 8 “End Poverty in Africa” fund raising concert were singing. “It was to amuse the crowds and to clear their own consciences,” Tonme said. “They still believe us to be like children that they must save, as if we don’t realize ourselves what the source of our problems is.”20 But “Bahá’u’lláh has come to free humanity from this long bondage, and the closing decades of the twentieth century were devoted by the community of His followers to creative experimen-tation with the means by which His objective can be realized.”21 Fidelity to the principle of oneness implies that the masses of mankind are ready and worthy of assuming their proper role as protagonists in their own development, rather than spectators looking on from a distance. This larger perspective is making some headway. One example can be found in recent news: The Norwegian Nobel Committee, in awarding the 2006 Peace Prize to Muhammad Yunus, founder of the Grameen Bank, declared, “Every single individual on earth has both the potential and the right to live a decent life… even the poorest of the poor can work to bring about their own development…. Development from below also serves to advance democracy and human rights.”22 If it can be accepted that the spirit of the age is moving mankind, consciously or not, toward the oneness of humanity and that this dynamic involves mobilizing the spiritual strength of each person, then it follows that approaches which ignore or resist this tectonic societal shift must, sooner or later, fail. On the other hand, approaches aligned with the social and spiritual reality of our time must eventually prosper and produce lasting results. The Bahá’í experience in devel-opment illustrates an attempt to achieve such an alignment. Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress
9
The two previous publications in this series23 illustrate that American Bahá’í youth and adults are actively engaged in development and are animated to improve the life of society by such basic precepts of their Faith as the principle that work and service are forms of worship. Their commitment to this process is thus an “expression of faith in action;” their approach consists of five main elements: • Consultation: A process of collective decision-making and action through which individuals and communities strive to become the principal actors in promoting their physical, spiritual and social well-being; improvement in the ability of participants to consult is therefore a primary measure of success in any Bahá’í project. • Participatory Learning: Consultation is used to promote participatory learning within the framework of many Bahá’í projects. Positive change in society directly springs from the generation, application and diffusion of knowledge, which has both material and spiritual dimensions, and which can flow from both rational inquiry and spiritual insight. • Organic Growth: Successful social initiatives often begin with simple actions at the community level and grow in complexity as the community learns to identify its needs and take on more complex issues, with residents defining, pacing and assessing the projects that affect their lives. Outside entities also may play a catalytic role in helping communities realize their aspirations. • Moral Development: In a community that operates in a peaceful, prosperous and fair way, its members adhere to ideals of human honor, duty and integrity; create an environment where these ideals are consistently demon-strated; and build institutions that engender trust, and uplift and encourage all whom they serve. To attain these goals, specific moral capabilities must be developed so that individuals and institutions can make appropriate moral choices. • Unity, Equality and Justice: Fostering unity of purpose within and outside the Bahá’í community is an essential characteristic of all Bahá’í development activity. It is a unity that embraces diversity and refuses to categorize people by race, creed, class, gender or color. Unity, however, requires conditions of equality and justice, when every member of the community can trust that they are protected by standards and assured of benefits that apply to all. As Bahá’u’lláh explains, “The purpose of justice is the appearance of unity among men.” The current report includes information gathered from recent interviews of participants in projects that were studied in the two previous rounds. Participants were asked why they feel their work has value; which principles they found applied most directly to their work; what practical lessons they learned about sustainability; and what they might have done differently in light of their experience. The implicit goal of the interviews was to determine how these projects integrate spiritual awareness with practical action and how they are aligned with the forces moving mankind toward the realization of its oneness. Toward Alignment The two previous publications in this series23 illustrate that American Bahá’í youth and adults are actively engaged in development and are animated to improve the life of society by such basic precepts of their Faith as the principle that work and service are forms of worship. Their commitment to this process is thus an “expression of faith in action;” their approach consists of five main elements: • Consultation: A process of collective decision-making and action through which individuals and communities strive to become the principal actors in promoting their physical, spiritual and social well-being; improvement in the ability of participants to consult is therefore a primary measure of success in any Bahá’í project. • Participatory Learning: Consultation is used to promote participatory learning within the framework of many Bahá’í projects. Positive change in society directly springs from the generation, application and diffusion of knowledge, which has both material and spiritual dimensions, and which can flow from both rational inquiry and spiritual insight. • Organic Growth: Successful social initiatives often begin with simple actions at the community level and grow in complexity as the community learns to identify its needs and take on more complex issues, with residents defining, pacing and assessing the projects that affect their lives. Outside entities also may play a catalytic role in helping communities realize their aspirations. • Moral Development: In a community that operates in a peaceful, prosperous and fair way, its members adhere to ideals of human honor, duty and integrity; create an environment where these ideals are consistently demon-strated; and build institutions that engender trust, and uplift and encourage all whom they serve. To attain these goals, specific moral capabilities must be developed so that individuals and institutions can make appropriate moral choices. • Unity, Equality and Justice: Fostering unity of purpose within and outside the Bahá’í community is an essential characteristic of all Bahá’í development activity. It is a unity that embraces diversity and refuses to categorize people by race, creed, class, gender or color. Unity, however, requires conditions of equality and justice, when every member of the community can trust that they are protected by standards and assured of benefits that apply to all. As Bahá’u’lláh explains, “The purpose of justice is the appearance of unity among men.” The current report includes information gathered from recent interviews of participants in projects that were studied in the two previous rounds. Participants were asked why they feel their work has value; which principles they found applied most directly to their work; what practical lessons they learned about sustainability; and what they might have done differently in light of their experience. The implicit goal of the interviews was to determine how these projects integrate spiritual awareness with practical action and how they are aligned with the forces moving mankind toward the realization of its oneness. Toward Alignment 10
In Service to the Common Good
Relationships and Commitment Promoting oneness shapes the way field work-ers think about and develop relationships: Are local residents really encouraged and supported in becoming full partners, for example? When asked about the value of their work, nearly all this year’s interviewees echoed the words of one young person involved with Orien Aid, which sends youth to Rwanda to work in villages on local projects: “It’s the relationships, no question. We have made a commitment to the people, and we intend to fulfill it, and they know that. They know we will come, they look forward to it, and each time our relationships grow deeper.” The primary reason for going on the project, said another Orien Aid volunteer, “was not to give a nutrition class. It was to make a connection and to show love to people. This way, I also learned far more than I gave.” Speaking about conditions in Rwanda, where Orien Aid has just completed the third year of its five-year commitment, this participant said, “The biggest part of the project for me was the service: It’s about showing the people we visited that someone still cares about them. Who spends $3,000 to go sleep three nights, five nights in a village in Africa, or to walk three hours to get to that village? They don’t see many outsiders. I don’t recall seeing any, or any aid workers from other organizations, although I did see more of those in the city.” A businesswoman in New Jersey, one of the adult organizers of the Karen Wallace Service Project (KWSP), which has worked for eight years with an AIDS orphanage in Yasothon, Thailand, said, “I think the big difference is the relationships that form between the volunteers and the local people, the kids. They really connect; it’s real.” Other organizations work for two or three months, she said, “and then they go, and the kids know they aren’t part of those visitors’ lives anymore. We have commit-ted, and even when we’re not there, we’re focused on these children and the next stage of the project, so they know we’re thinking of them all the time and that we will come back, as we’ve prom-ised. That brings a level of trust and confidence that is very real.” One of the founders of the Children’s Theatre Company (CTC), whose home base is in lower Manhattan in New York City, agrees that constant and consistent involvement is key to the success of a program. “I spend several days each week visiting families and relatives of the kids, in their homes, building the community that’s needed to support each child, showing them we’re there, we’re involved,” she said. “We have a dialogue with parents about how they want to raise their children and how we can support those goals. We definitely take advan-tage of the cultural richness that’s around us in our communities.” A retired educator who helped found the Women On the Move Network, which works with young girls from low income backgrounds, put it succinctly: “We go to them; we don’t make them come to us. I am not ‘Lady Bountiful.’” From Spectator to Protagonist To achieve unity, individuals must make the shift from being spectators to becoming actors in their own lives. The young people involved with Orien Aid, for example, are proudest of the fact that during their most recent stay they Relationships and Commitment Promoting oneness shapes the way field work-ers think about and develop relationships: Are local residents really encouraged and supported in becoming full partners, for example? When asked about the value of their work, nearly all this year’s interviewees echoed the words of one young person involved with Orien Aid, which sends youth to Rwanda to work in villages on local projects: “It’s the relationships, no question. We have made a commitment to the people, and we intend to fulfill it, and they know that. They know we will come, they look forward to it, and each time our relationships grow deeper.” The primary reason for going on the project, said another Orien Aid volunteer, “was not to give a nutrition class. It was to make a connection and to show love to people. This way, I also learned far more than I gave.” Speaking about conditions in Rwanda, where Orien Aid has just completed the third year of its five-year commitment, this participant said, “The biggest part of the project for me was the service: It’s about showing the people we visited that someone still cares about them. Who spends $3,000 to go sleep three nights, five nights in a village in Africa, or to walk three hours to get to that village? They don’t see many outsiders. I don’t recall seeing any, or any aid workers from other organizations, although I did see more of those in the city.” A businesswoman in New Jersey, one of the adult organizers of the Karen Wallace Service Project (KWSP), which has worked for eight years with an AIDS orphanage in Yasothon, Thailand, said, “I think the big difference is the relationships that form between the volunteers and the local people, the kids. They really connect; it’s real.” Other organizations work for two or three months, she said, “and then they go, and the kids know they aren’t part of those visitors’ lives anymore. We have commit-ted, and even when we’re not there, we’re focused on these children and the next stage of the project, so they know we’re thinking of them all the time and that we will come back, as we’ve prom-ised. That brings a level of trust and confidence that is very real.” One of the founders of the Children’s Theatre Company (CTC), whose home base is in lower Manhattan in New York City, agrees that constant and consistent involvement is key to the success of a program. “I spend several days each week visiting families and relatives of the kids, in their homes, building the community that’s needed to support each child, showing them we’re there, we’re involved,” she said. “We have a dialogue with parents about how they want to raise their children and how we can support those goals. We definitely take advan-tage of the cultural richness that’s around us in our communities.” A retired educator who helped found the Women On the Move Network, which works with young girls from low income backgrounds, put it succinctly: “We go to them; we don’t make them come to us. I am not ‘Lady Bountiful.’” From Spectator to Protagonist To achieve unity, individuals must make the shift from being spectators to becoming actors in their own lives. The young people involved with Orien Aid, for example, are proudest of the fact that during their most recent stay they Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress
11
saw how the confidence of local people had reached a level that enabled them to take the initiative: “In earlier visits, we had offered so many things, and the people kind of felt bad about how little they had to offer,” said an Orien Aid volunteer. “This year, our work stressed nutrition and cleanliness, at the request of some of the local organizers. Our classes and other activities mixed children and adults, but the parents took more control. We saw they were ready to do whole classes, so we stepped back and just supported them, and the whole feeling changed. They felt really good about them-selves. I think everyone on the team felt this was the best moment; we were all proud to have gotten to that point.” KWSP has, in effect, built its entire project around the shift from spectator to protagonist, using consultation as the means. The young participants, whose opin-ions are so often discounted in American society, take responsibility for most of the logistical preparations in the U.S., while program-planning starts fresh each year with input from counter-parts in Thailand. There is a constant flow of communication among program participants in the United States as they get ready for their trip, and between the U.S. and Thailand over themes, priorities and itineraries. “All year we are consulting about the goals and needs of the people locally,” said one participant. “They tell us what issues are relevant to a place they want our team to go, then onsite we make the final decisions with the local people. The whole project is shaped through consultation with the people who live there.” Integrating Spirit and Method In the projects that have been studied between 2004 and 2006, the emerging trend is greater clarity among participants about the spiritual foundations of their work. Their see their motives as more explicitly related to the teachings of their Faith; they have a stronger sense of mission, which stems from those teachings; and their methods of operation are more directly linked to a sense of the spiritual. When asked why, out of all the activities they might do as Bahá’ís, they have chosen service through development, the volunteers say, “We have a clear conviction of equality as a spiritual principle;” “We believe that when girls and women receive equal education with their male peers, and reach decision-making arenas, war will cease;” “Unity in diversity is not only about race, though that is an issue in our area, but it is also economic—it is in the gifts people have to bring, even if they themselves don’t see their importance—and it is about religion;” “Our approach is really derived from the (Bahá’í) teachings, so we take seriously the notion of relieving extremes of wealth and poverty.” The retired teacher again put it concisely: “You see three tired old girls like me, huffing and puffing around, trying to do this instead of taking it easy. There has to be some-thing more going on here!” One young person saw the difficulty that arose when his team departed from the high spiritual standards it espoused: “I would make it more spiritually focused, so that the group would progress more, spiritually, as a group. This doesn’t have to do with the mission; it has to do saw how the confidence of local people had reached a level that enabled them to take the initiative: “In earlier visits, we had offered so many things, and the people kind of felt bad about how little they had to offer,” said an Orien Aid volunteer. “This year, our work stressed nutrition and cleanliness, at the request of some of the local organizers. Our classes and other activities mixed children and adults, but the parents took more control. We saw they were ready to do whole classes, so we stepped back and just supported them, and the whole feeling changed. They felt really good about them-selves. I think everyone on the team felt this was the best moment; we were all proud to have gotten to that point.” KWSP has, in effect, built its entire project around the shift from spectator to protagonist, using consultation as the means. The young participants, whose opin-ions are so often discounted in American society, take responsibility for most of the logistical preparations in the U.S., while program-planning starts fresh each year with input from counter-parts in Thailand. There is a constant flow of communication among program participants in the United States as they get ready for their trip, and between the U.S. and Thailand over themes, priorities and itineraries. “All year we are consulting about the goals and needs of the people locally,” said one participant. “They tell us what issues are relevant to a place they want our team to go, then onsite we make the final decisions with the local people. The whole project is shaped through consultation with the people who live there.” Integrating Spirit and Method In the projects that have been studied between 2004 and 2006, the emerging trend is greater clarity among participants about the spiritual foundations of their work. Their see their motives as more explicitly related to the teachings of their Faith; they have a stronger sense of mission, which stems from those teachings; and their methods of operation are more directly linked to a sense of the spiritual. When asked why, out of all the activities they might do as Bahá’ís, they have chosen service through development, the volunteers say, “We have a clear conviction of equality as a spiritual principle;” “We believe that when girls and women receive equal education with their male peers, and reach decision-making arenas, war will cease;” “Unity in diversity is not only about race, though that is an issue in our area, but it is also economic—it is in the gifts people have to bring, even if they themselves don’t see their importance—and it is about religion;” “Our approach is really derived from the (Bahá’í) teachings, so we take seriously the notion of relieving extremes of wealth and poverty.” The retired teacher again put it concisely: “You see three tired old girls like me, huffing and puffing around, trying to do this instead of taking it easy. There has to be some-thing more going on here!” One young person saw the difficulty that arose when his team departed from the high spiritual standards it espoused: “I would make it more spiritually focused, so that the group would progress more, spiritually, as a group. This doesn’t have to do with the mission; it has to do 12
In Service to the Common Good
with the way we do the mission. The group was already very unified, but I think if we had spent more structured time praying together, studying together, bringing consultation to all the oppor-tunities we had to really use it, then everything would have been better, deeper. There was one person who was not very happy during this visit, and I think it had to do with expectations and not taking time to deepen our spiritual unity.” The Children’s Theatre Company uses art to promote moral development, which has result-ed in participants’ spiritual growth as well as expansion of the company’s programs and out-side support. “We use professional artists to work with the kids, and we combine drama, music and ethical education to produce full-scale plays and musicals. This is very different, and the parents and kids recognize this. Say you are a high school teacher and you have the lux-ury of a small budget for theater or music. You have very few choices in what to do, so you do ‘Guys and Dolls,’ which is about gamblers and prostitutes. What kind of role models are these for kids? “The parents see their children developing all these skills, having fun and learning to dram-atize the words and lives of important, noble people, so the program speaks to their spiritual development, too. Instead of learning a popular song about sex and stuff, they learn about Gandhi, Martin Luther King and world peace. Who wouldn’t choose that for their child?” Practical Lessons Participants in the projects that were revisited in 2006 report having learned important practical lessons in addition to the larger spiritual ones. A member of the Women on the Move Network (WOTMN) said, “We were intrigued by the story of the Tahirih Justice Center that we read in the first ‘In Service’ booklet (2004). We contacted them and they helped us very generously to re-think our approach. We realize now we should have applied for our 501(c)(3) non-profit status much earlier.” That sentiment was echoed by a participant in another project: “What would we do differently? Get our 501(c)(3) early.” The WOTMN participant said her group learned other practical lessons: “We started doing too many things at once, and most of them involved only costs, not income. Now we focus more on our mission statement, and evaluate what we do in relation to the mission, the resources available and the costs involved. Now our semi-annual conference, which used to be an end in itself, supports the girls and the pilot project directly through fundraising, publicity, as a laboratory where the girls practice what they are learning and as a source of connections for our future growth.” “Focus and devote more time to the projects than we have currently allotted,” said a represen-tative of Women for International Peace and Arbitration (WIPA), which for the last 20 years has with the way we do the mission. The group was already very unified, but I think if we had spent more structured time praying together, studying together, bringing consultation to all the oppor-tunities we had to really use it, then everything would have been better, deeper. There was one person who was not very happy during this visit, and I think it had to do with expectations and not taking time to deepen our spiritual unity.” The Children’s Theatre Company uses art to promote moral development, which has result-ed in participants’ spiritual growth as well as expansion of the company’s programs and out-side support. “We use professional artists to work with the kids, and we combine drama, music and ethical education to produce full-scale plays and musicals. This is very different, and the parents and kids recognize this. Say you are a high school teacher and you have the lux-ury of a small budget for theater or music. You have very few choices in what to do, so you do ‘Guys and Dolls,’ which is about gamblers and prostitutes. What kind of role models are these for kids? “The parents see their children developing all these skills, having fun and learning to dram-atize the words and lives of important, noble people, so the program speaks to their spiritual development, too. Instead of learning a popular song about sex and stuff, they learn about Gandhi, Martin Luther King and world peace. Who wouldn’t choose that for their child?” Practical Lessons Participants in the projects that were revisited in 2006 report having learned important practical lessons in addition to the larger spiritual ones. A member of the Women on the Move Network (WOTMN) said, “We were intrigued by the story of the Tahirih Justice Center that we read in the first ‘In Service’ booklet (2004). We contacted them and they helped us very generously to re-think our approach. We realize now we should have applied for our 501(c)(3) non-profit status much earlier.” That sentiment was echoed by a participant in another project: “What would we do differently? Get our 501(c)(3) early.” The WOTMN participant said her group learned other practical lessons: “We started doing too many things at once, and most of them involved only costs, not income. Now we focus more on our mission statement, and evaluate what we do in relation to the mission, the resources available and the costs involved. Now our semi-annual conference, which used to be an end in itself, supports the girls and the pilot project directly through fundraising, publicity, as a laboratory where the girls practice what they are learning and as a source of connections for our future growth.” “Focus and devote more time to the projects than we have currently allotted,” said a represen-tative of Women for International Peace and Arbitration (WIPA), which for the last 20 years has Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress
13
sponsored girls’ education in various parts of the world. “We would also devote more time to our chapter network to ensure they are successful, to fan the spark of interest that attracted them and to ensure the timely receipt of their financial reports.” Other projects learned lessons on the impor-tance of training and orientation, particularly where cross-cultural issues come into play. “I’d have a briefing book of some kind,” said a coordinator for KWSP, “and probably some kind of contract covering behavior, because I don’t want to have to be a parent for the group, which takes some-thing important away from the whole feeling of the thing. Thai culture is very modest, for example, and we had one instance of very inappropriate dress—normal in the U.S., but not right for Thailand. I would try to avoid that.” Orien Aid, which ran short on time to train for its 2006 season, cited the same need: “You have to train at least four months in advance, so that if there are problems, you have some options,” said one participant. “Training in-country is important, and there has to be a balance, but once you have gotten there, it’s kind of too late if there’s a problem, if expectations are too dif-ferent from the reality on the ground.” Sustainability—More Than Funding Members of the projects that were revisited also reflected on the spiritual and practical implications of sustainability in their work. On the practical side, the WIPA representative highlighted a lesson participants learned about fundraising: “It is more appealing if you have a clear vision with a manageable, targeted outcome that actually changes the lives of those you are serv-ing. We were struggling to raise funds until we discovered that we had to describe our mission in ways people could identify with; then we found they give both time and money.” CTC has found that “you have to surround yourself with people you want to hang out with in a meaningful way. And we find we need to go in short spurts of activity—we have two 15-week sessions, with a break in between. We need to create a culture of service so everyone feels a part of this, and everyone feels his or her contri-bution is valued. We do this in relation to our tuition and fees, for example. In most settings, people who can afford to pay full tuition get spe-cial treatment; we don’t do that. We have worked hard to make sure that everyone contributes what they have, and that diversity is valued so no one thinks any less of the parent who pays by cleaning up instead of writing a check.” Members of the Bahá’í community have many demands on their time, because there is no clergy to do many of the tasks an active community requires. Project members were asked why they had chosen development over some of the other possibilities. “We looked at letters from the Universal House of Justice (the world-wide governing body of the Bahá’í com-munity), where they talk about certain activities that require expertise and that must continue,” said one participant. “We felt WOTMN was one of those. We have something unique to share, and a population of young women who are at sponsored girls’ education in various parts of the world. “We would also devote more time to our chapter network to ensure they are successful, to fan the spark of interest that attracted them and to ensure the timely receipt of their financial reports.” Other projects learned lessons on the impor-tance of training and orientation, particularly where cross-cultural issues come into play. “I’d have a briefing book of some kind,” said a coordinator for KWSP, “and probably some kind of contract covering behavior, because I don’t want to have to be a parent for the group, which takes some-thing important away from the whole feeling of the thing. Thai culture is very modest, for example, and we had one instance of very inappropriate dress—normal in the U.S., but not right for Thailand. I would try to avoid that.” Orien Aid, which ran short on time to train for its 2006 season, cited the same need: “You have to train at least four months in advance, so that if there are problems, you have some options,” said one participant. “Training in-country is important, and there has to be a balance, but once you have gotten there, it’s kind of too late if there’s a problem, if expectations are too dif-ferent from the reality on the ground.” Sustainability—More Than Funding Members of the projects that were revisited also reflected on the spiritual and practical implications of sustainability in their work. On the practical side, the WIPA representative highlighted a lesson participants learned about fundraising: “It is more appealing if you have a clear vision with a manageable, targeted outcome that actually changes the lives of those you are serv-ing. We were struggling to raise funds until we discovered that we had to describe our mission in ways people could identify with; then we found they give both time and money.” CTC has found that “you have to surround yourself with people you want to hang out with in a meaningful way. And we find we need to go in short spurts of activity—we have two 15-week sessions, with a break in between. We need to create a culture of service so everyone feels a part of this, and everyone feels his or her contri-bution is valued. We do this in relation to our tuition and fees, for example. In most settings, people who can afford to pay full tuition get spe-cial treatment; we don’t do that. We have worked hard to make sure that everyone contributes what they have, and that diversity is valued so no one thinks any less of the parent who pays by cleaning up instead of writing a check.” Members of the Bahá’í community have many demands on their time, because there is no clergy to do many of the tasks an active community requires. Project members were asked why they had chosen development over some of the other possibilities. “We looked at letters from the Universal House of Justice (the world-wide governing body of the Bahá’í com-munity), where they talk about certain activities that require expertise and that must continue,” said one participant. “We felt WOTMN was one of those. We have something unique to share, and a population of young women who are at 14
In Service to the Common Good
risk, and whom we have to reach. We’re concerned about the waste of those lives if they get caught up in all the things that pull them into dysfunctional attitudes and actions.” The CTC coordinator said, “I had to look at what I can do, where I have some expertise and I asked myself, ‘What can I do with the little time I have available to impact the largest number of people?’ I saw my friends, starving artists, and realized we could nourish our own growth by using our art. This is as much about the artists themselves as it is the children. We’re not ‘res-cuing’ anybody.” “This isn’t really something that worries me,” said a member of Voicemail for the Homeless, a San Francisco area project, “this competition for attention among all the activities I ‘should’ do. This is my passion. Service through develop-ment is just doing what comes naturally to me.” “Making service a part of your life, even if you’re not in the field,” is a part of sustainability in the KWSP. “Partly that’s going back every year, and partly it is the ongoing work that has to happen in order to be able to go back into the field,” a project member explained. “The continuity of effort also makes for stronger relationships with the people in Thailand and a better reception when we arrive each time.” Making development and service a part of their lives is a common thread running through the comments of those interviewed. Consider the WOTMN representative who served the Bahá’í community in Costa Rica for 16 years until economic reasons forced her to return to the U.S., where she taught English until retire-ment, and then helped to form the Network. One of the founders of the interfaith Jeffco Partners, which collab-orated with Habitat for Humanity to build 10 houses for refugees in the Denver area, lived in Bolivia in the 1970s, returned to a college teaching job and later became involved in Jeffco. Now that Jeffco has completed its task and moved in a different direction, he and his wife are retiring to Bolivia to participate in other community development projects. Young people are also making service a central focus of their lives and career choices. One of Orien Aid’s 2006 team members expressed his passion for service by saying, “I grew up in Africa and want to return there. The project helped to refine my goal of being a visual journalist, but I realized I needed to go to graduate school to build my skills. I want to bring awareness to the plight of disadvantaged people; I want to take my skills back to Africa and do that.” “Participating in activities of social change should not be restricted to traditional service endeavors,” said a graduate school student who devoted several summers to various projects. “One of the greatest tasks of Bahá’ís is to effect change in their everyday interactions; we are charged to be the embodiments of our religious beliefs, advocating for the regeneration of humanity… . I cannot believe that our task is solely to sit back and watch, do our prescribed sequence of training courses, say our prayers and hope for hearts to change…the spirit (of the early Bahá’ís) must be infused in our everyday actions. We have to be of service in our every-day activities, within our own communities, because this is the only way to be true champions of social justice.” risk, and whom we have to reach. We’re concerned about the waste of those lives if they get caught up in all the things that pull them into dysfunctional attitudes and actions.” The CTC coordinator said, “I had to look at what I can do, where I have some expertise and I asked myself, ‘What can I do with the little time I have available to impact the largest number of people?’ I saw my friends, starving artists, and realized we could nourish our own growth by using our art. This is as much about the artists themselves as it is the children. We’re not ‘res-cuing’ anybody.” “This isn’t really something that worries me,” said a member of Voicemail for the Homeless, a San Francisco area project, “this competition for attention among all the activities I ‘should’ do. This is my passion. Service through develop-ment is just doing what comes naturally to me.” “Making service a part of your life, even if you’re not in the field,” is a part of sustainability in the KWSP. “Partly that’s going back every year, and partly it is the ongoing work that has to happen in order to be able to go back into the field,” a project member explained. “The continuity of effort also makes for stronger relationships with the people in Thailand and a better reception when we arrive each time.” Making development and service a part of their lives is a common thread running through the comments of those interviewed. Consider the WOTMN representative who served the Bahá’í community in Costa Rica for 16 years until economic reasons forced her to return to the U.S., where she taught English until retire-ment, and then helped to form the Network. One of the founders of the interfaith Jeffco Partners, which collab-orated with Habitat for Humanity to build 10 houses for refugees in the Denver area, lived in Bolivia in the 1970s, returned to a college teaching job and later became involved in Jeffco. Now that Jeffco has completed its task and moved in a different direction, he and his wife are retiring to Bolivia to participate in other community development projects. Young people are also making service a central focus of their lives and career choices. One of Orien Aid’s 2006 team members expressed his passion for service by saying, “I grew up in Africa and want to return there. The project helped to refine my goal of being a visual journalist, but I realized I needed to go to graduate school to build my skills. I want to bring awareness to the plight of disadvantaged people; I want to take my skills back to Africa and do that.” “Participating in activities of social change should not be restricted to traditional service endeavors,” said a graduate school student who devoted several summers to various projects.




























“One of the greatest tasks of Bahá’ís is to effect change in their everyday interactions; we are charged to be the embodiments of our religious beliefs, advocating for the regeneration of humanity… . I cannot believe that our task is solely to sit back and watch, do our prescribed sequence of training courses, say our prayers and hope for hearts to change…the spirit (of the early Bahá’ís) must be infused in our everyday actions. We have to be of service in our every-day activities, within our own communities, because this is the only way to be true champions of social justice.” Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress
15







Mathematicians who study complexity theory might describe these stories in terms of complex adaptive systems. They might point out that when a grain of sand finally pushes the system past its tipping point, setting off an avalanche of events that create wholly new patterns, it is possible only in retrospect to know which grain of sand it was that triggered the advent of a new reality. Others might describe these projects in terms of organic growth: Each project and its participants, consciously or not, are adapting to the social evolution underway as mankind struggles toward the realization of its own oneness. New alignments and opportunities emerge, and these individuals and the initiatives they have set in motion organize themselves accordingly. A remarkable characteristic of self-organizing systems is that one finds the same patterns emerging at every level of detail or magnification; the parts mirror the whole, down to the molecular level. As global society moves toward oneness, so do all of its component parts. Program participants who are Bahá’ís know that Bahá’u’lláh has urged them to be “anxiously concerned with the needs of the age ye live in,” and to “center your deliberations on its exigencies and requirements.” They also know that he has urged all people to work for the progress of civilization by integrating the spiritual and the material. Each of the participants in these projects has committed to that process, often for a lifetime, and they never stop searching for better ways to serve the common good. A Life-Time Quest Mathematicians who study complexity theory might describe these stories in terms of complex adaptive systems. They might point out that when a grain of sand finally pushes the system past its tipping point, setting off an avalanche of events that create wholly new patterns, it is possible only in retrospect to know which grain of sand it was that triggered the advent of a new reality. Others might describe these projects in terms of organic growth: Each project and its participants, consciously or not, are adapting to the social evolution underway as mankind struggles toward the realization of its own oneness. New alignments and opportunities emerge, and these individuals and the initiatives they have set in motion organize themselves accordingly. A remarkable characteristic of self-organizing systems is that one finds the same patterns emerging at every level of detail or magnification; the parts mirror the whole, down to the molecular level. As global society moves toward oneness, so do all of its component parts. Program participants who are Bahá’ís know that Bahá’u’lláh has urged them to be “anxiously concerned with the needs of the age ye live in,” and to “center your deliberations on its exigencies and requirements.” They also know that he has urged all people to work for the progress of civilization by integrating the spiritual and the material. Each of the participants in these projects has committed to that process, often for a lifetime, and they never stop searching for better ways to serve the common good. A Life-Time Quest 16
In Service to the Common Good
Photo Credits End Notes
Cover and page 12: Ryan Lash 1 Easterly (2006), p.4 Pages 1, 9 and 14: Orien Aid
2 Universal House of Justice, October 20, 1983
Pages 2, 7, 11, 15 and 16: KWSP
to the Bahá’ís of the World.
Page 13: Bill Aristovulos/Children’s Theatre Co.
3 Easterly, pp. 66-7.
Pages 4 and 10: William Allmart
4 See, for example, Development as Freedom (Dr. Amartya Sen, 2001).
References
Bahá’í World Center. Prosperity of Humankind. (1995) 5 Easterly, op. cit., p. 8. Century of Light. (2001) 6 Duflo, E; Dupas, P; Kremer, M; Sinei, S. (2006) Banerjee, A; Deaton, A.; Duflo, E. Health Care 7 Banerjee, A; Deaton, A.; Duflo, E. (2004)
Delivery in Rural Rajasthan. (2004) Downloaded from
8 Kremer, M; Miguel, E. (2004)
www.povertyactionlab.org/papers, October 2006.
9 Gugerty, M.K.; Kremer, M. (2004)
Duflo, E; Dupas, P; Kremer, M; Sinei, S. Education
10 Bahá’í World Center, (2001), Century of Light, p.75
and HIV/AIDS Prevention: Evidence from a randomized evaluation in Western Kenya. (2006) Downloaded 11 McCusker, James, referring to Bob Geldof in from www.povertyactionlab.org/papers, October, 2006. “G-8 Countries Need To Wake Up” (Everett, WA
Herald, July 10, 2005)
Easterly, W. The White Man’s Burden: Why the West’s Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Much Ill 12 See The Universal House of Justice, Ridván 2006 and So Little Good. New York: Penguin Books. (2006) Message to the Bahá’ís of the World, p. 2 and passim.
Gugerty, M.K.; Kremer, M. The Rockefeller Effect. (2004) 13 The Prophet Founder of the Bahá’í Faith (1817-1892) Downloaded from www.povertyactionlab.org/papers, 14 Bahá’í World Center, Prosperity of Humankind, 1995, October 2006. para 11. Kremer, M.; Miguel, E. The Illusion of Sustainability. 15 Ibid., para. 6. (2004) Downloaded from www.povertyactionlab.org/
16 Ibid., para. 42.
papers, October 2006.
17 Ibid. , para. 7.
Sen, A. Development As Freedom. New York:
18 Duly, Greg, “Creating Violence-Free Society:
Alfred Knopf. (2001)
The Case for Rwanda,” in The Journal of
Taylor, M. C.; The Moment of Complexity: Emerging
Humanitarian Assistance, 2000; downloaded
Network Culture. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
from http://www.jha.ac/greatlakes/b002.htm
(2002)
19 Bahá’í World Center, (2001), Century of Light, p. 4.
For additional information, please see: 20 “All Rock, No Action,” New York Times, World Order of Bahá'u'lláh. Wilmette, IL: Bahá'í July 15, 2005 Publishing Trust.
21 Bahá'í World Center, op. cit., p. 110.
Valuing Spirituality in Development
22 Quoted in New York Times, October 12, 2006.
(http://statements.bahai.org/98-0218.htm)
23 In Service to the Common Good: The American
Who Is Writing the Future?
Bahá’í Community’s Commitment to Social Change
Reflections on the Twentieth Century;
(Evanston, 2004); and In Service to the Common
(http://info.bahai.org/article-1-7-3-1.html)
Good: Bahá’í Youth in their Own Words In Service to the Common Good; (Evanston, 2005). (http://www.bahai.us/in-service-to-the-common-good)
Copyright © 2006 National Spiritual Assembly of the Bahá’ís of the United States. All rights reserved.
Aligning Development with the Forces of Progress
Bahá’í National Center 1233 Central Street Evanston, IL 60201-1611 USA http://www.us.bahai.org/ 1-800-22-UNITE